Re:New Type of Early Stage Investment Firm
by meredydd on Tuesday April 29, 2008 @05:05AM
(#176426)
I have to say, I'm fairly sanguine.
I mean, the worst it can do is not make much money, right? And whether it succeeds or fails, it will provide a real-world test of those assertions that ideas really are worthless, rather than just highly illiquid assets.
I think they have at least a decent chance - provided that the tech guys get a sufficient proportion of the equity they take that they have skin in the game. I watch with interest.
Re:New Type of Early Stage Investment Firm
by jsomers on Tuesday April 29, 2008 @12:28AM
(#176300)
Seems like a formula for (a) half-assery on the part of developers working on someone else's baby, and (b) incessant nagging from the "idea guys" who can neither communicate their feature requests nor understand their implications.
In short, a hip "seed" version of the company where Dilbert worked.
Re:New Type of Early Stage Investment Firm
by bigbang on Tuesday April 29, 2008 @06:23PM
(#177063)
Well, they would choose the idea only if they like it, so imo its not that bad. I mean you pitch your idea to somebody, if they like it, they are in (pretty much like finding a co-founder), not sure if they have any say in features?
Re:New Type of Early Stage Investment Firm
by yankees1 on Tuesday April 29, 2008 @12:54AM
(#176320)
i'm looking for some information here...how do you not be an "idea guy" if you have ideas? I have detailed business requirements, well thought out mockups, use cases, I listen well, "stay out of the kitchen", what else?
Re:New Type of Early Stage Investment Firm
by ericb on Tuesday April 29, 2008 @09:27AM
(#176504)
I'd say contribute in as many other capacities as possible, like sales, accounting, PR, business dev, etc. Make the final vision a shared one, and don't consider "the idea" to be what entitles you to the fruits of the business.
Re:New Type of Early Stage Investment Firm
by yankees1 on Monday April 28, 2008 @11:58PM
(#176281)
I think I might give this a shot. I recently posted looking for a developer to work with as a co-founder and only had one bite. I'm going down the outsourcing route with one idea right now. I'm also trying to teach myself Ruby as I type this entry. I've seen lots of complaints here from developers dealing with douchebag MBAs. I'd like to find some developers with some balls to invest their time without putting cash in their hands.
Re:New Type of Early Stage Investment Firm
by david927 on Tuesday April 29, 2008 @03:26AM
(#176398)
Outsourcing is your best shot, in my opinion. It's what I do, even though I'm a developer myself. I just don't have the time. It only takes a few thousand and you can have any app developed. The technical decisions are critical. I wouldn't trust someone else, such as this company, to make those decisions for me.
I mean, the worst it can do is not make much money, right? And whether it succeeds or fails, it will provide a real-world test of those assertions that ideas really are worthless, rather than just highly illiquid assets.
I think they have at least a decent chance - provided that the tech guys get a sufficient proportion of the equity they take that they have skin in the game. I watch with interest.
In short, a hip "seed" version of the company where Dilbert worked.
So sketch