News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by mustacheemperor on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:15PM (#17605003)
I saw the above comment not as equating free speech supporters to white ethnic-nationalists, but as criticizing conflating white ethnic-nationalists with free speech supporters. There are a lot of people with ideas very different from mine who are not dangerous racists, and I’m happy to share a social network with them. The remainder can stay on stormfront, which continues to exist because of the free speech rights you refer to. (And which would presumably immediately ban anyone who arrived professing non-racist viewpoints).
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by MrLeap on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:48PM (#17605237)
I get the impression the guy above you is grey because people disagree with him more than him being off topic, or not adding to the discussion. I'm going to try my hand at going even more off topic. Not just to dick with people, but this thread made me think about it and I think it adds to the conversation.

I've been playing a game that's basically a feudalism simulator recently, and I've found it interesting how familiar the dynamics of feudalism seem. I've started thinking about how the social contract that protected the tyrannies they were subject to still go on today. Transformed a bit, but not at all weakened.

We have a court spymaster leaving, but making a final declaration to the noble houses that the kingdom he is leaving has a responsibility use its power to control some people more, some information less. Then the guy at the top of the comment chain is like a peasant (in the feudal sense, I'm not trash talking) who is happy to see his liege wield his tyranny against people he doesn't like.

Then someone responds by pressing the power of another title (the first amendment). It's an uphill battle for him though. The empire (The United States) has nearly a hundred year precedent that the first amendment doesn't apply to kingdoms with a government type of "corporation".

I don't have a strong opinion about this. I do miss my view of counter-racist action in the 90's. I liked the memory of black service members defending dirty racists from violence, and the caption on the image being something like "I don't agree with a damn thing you're saying but I signed up to protect your right to say it!"

Stuff like that made me feel like we weren't just objectively right, but had a moral high-ground. More and more often it's feeling like a lesser of two evils.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by aldoushuxley001 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:22PM (#17605058)
Fair, but I would suggest that the above comment really is equating free speech supporters with white ethnic-nationalists. It's just implicit rather than explicit.

To quote ashleyn: 'Very tired of this "free speech" refrain... facebook is under no legal obligation to extend white ethno-nationalists a platform or support their cause in any capacity'

ashleyn may not have intended it, but their comment implies those who are using the "free speech" refrain are white ethnic-nationalists.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by mozumder on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:33PM (#17605133)
It's Facebook's editorial policy to allow hate speech. It has nothing to do with not limiting "free speech".

They allow it because it expands their audience.

Facebook isn't government. It can do what it wishes, including banning or allowing free speech, and has no obligations either way.

Given that, if I was a major advertiser, I'd steer clear of them considering that I might have my beautiful fashion ad next to some neo-Nazi propaganda.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by AmericanChopper on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:41PM (#17605185)
If there was any real definition of what "hate speech" is, then allowing it or not might be a more serious issue.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by ashleyn on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:20PM (#17605044)
I never equated the two. The government is still under the obligation to treat all speech equivalently. However, for a private citizen or corporation to extend a platform to these people is a very ethically problematic act, one that transcends this already-questionable notion that private citizens owe each other a chance to be heard.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by aldoushuxley001 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:28PM (#17605103)
I believe you did actually equate the two, just implicitly rather than explicitly. May not have even realized you were doing it.

That being said, I do agree with you that private corporations are under no obligation to respect free speech laws that mainly only apply to the government. Facebook is free to do as it pleases regarding who to censor or who not to.

In regards to extending a platform to people who's ideas you disagree with... I think we're just going to have to agree to disagree on this one. First, it's often wayyy to difficult to draw the line between acceptable and not. Secondly, I'd rather have racists and idiots explicitly write out their views so that we can have a conservation with them rather than causing them to go underground where their views understandably fester and become more extreme due to persecution and lack of other viewpoints.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by bena on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:35PM (#17605151)
Why?

If a private citizen sets up an "open mic" of sorts that anyone can use to espouse their viewpoints because they believe in "free speech", why is that "ethically problematic"?

Facebook doesn't owe it to anyone, but then again, there's no good reason for them not to do it either.