iPod: contracted.
iTunes: bought.
Most of the pro tools: bought.
Computers: integration of OEM parts.
Displays: rebadged.
And they've been able to gain marketshare like crazy and release products that people lust for. On the consumer front what has Microsoft presented to the world even with their massive research division? Talking Barney dolls? A house full of quirky tech they keep showing off every chance they get? Surface? Zune? Xbox?
The physical manufacturing, yeah, but I'm pretty sure the hardware designers are Apple employees.
"iTunes: bought."
The basis for it was purchased, yes. It was nothing like it is now.
The thing with Apple is that they tend to take germs of ideas and see them through to full realization. Mac OS, you could say, was just a clone of the OS that ran the Xerox Star. But the Star's OS was crude compared to the Mac's (even in the earliest versions).
iTunes was bought, sure the codebase (rebooted from 4.0 and onward) is different but it was bought in. Just like almost all the pro tools and that has now since been revamped.
My point still stands: after Steve Jobs came back what Apple has really done well is taking parts/ideas off the shelves and developing them into wonderful consumer products.
Keyword: Seems.
Yes, if you're preaching to the converted, that's proof enough, but Apple has rebadged BSD and has gotten a large degree of success through a remake of a 1979 device, the Sony Walkman. But those aren't really innovations at all. Shiny object!=innovation. I don't know how else to put it.
Here's microsoft's research page,
http://research.microsoft.com/research/default.aspx
Here's, umm, Apple's
http://www.apple.com/education/research/
...or, at least, that's the 1st link for the search query, "Apple Research":
Hmm, the page you’re looking for can’t be found.
A 404.