True, it'll be a tough blow to serve all that food for cheap, but if you can make people feel good about your restaurant for cheap, I think there is a good chance they'll be back, even if they have to pay more.
It's the reason why national brands can charge such a premium over generic stuff, even when it's exactly the same thing. People are risk averse and a Groupon takes half the risk out of a meal purchase.
I bet the average person would go back and/or recommend the restaurant to friends if they had a good experience though.
"The 32% that said they didn’t make a profit from the program reported that customers rarely bought more than the coupon deal and few returned to the business at a later date."
If over 68% of the customers returned, then I'd call that a huge success.
I can guarantee that there's going to be a teeth whitening deal every week - so why would I ever go back to a dentist and pay full price? Long term, these businesses are damaging their markets and industries. You'll struggle to build a business from fickle, deal-hunting customers.
That said, with things that are unusual I think Groupon is a good solution - a canoe trip, or climbing wall for example. There's less competition and it's a great way for people to try something that they might grow to love. But restaurants - come on!
It's like the reverse of a loyalty card - come again and we'll charge you double.