Re:Users Sue Juul for Addicting Them to Nicotine
by smt88 on Monday July 23, 2018 @06:31PM
(#17596562)
I don't have the energy to get into the history of this type of lawsuit, but in US common law (and under some statutes, too), companies may be sued when the user of a product has a reasonable expectation that a product will perform one way, and then it performs another.
The most famous (and universally misunderstood[1]) case is the woman who got 3rd-degree, flesh-falling-off burns from McDonald's coffee and sued them successfully.
It was reasonable for the woman to expect hot coffee, as one would find in one's home. McDonald's served her much hotter coffee without warning her beforehand, which led to her underestimating how dangerous handling that coffee could be.
All McDonald's had to do was tell her it was very hot.
Juul is in a worse position because engineering addiction is much more malicious than engineering extra-hot coffee that saves the company money.
The most famous (and universally misunderstood[1]) case is the woman who got 3rd-degree, flesh-falling-off burns from McDonald's coffee and sued them successfully.
It was reasonable for the woman to expect hot coffee, as one would find in one's home. McDonald's served her much hotter coffee without warning her beforehand, which led to her underestimating how dangerous handling that coffee could be.
All McDonald's had to do was tell her it was very hot.
Juul is in a worse position because engineering addiction is much more malicious than engineering extra-hot coffee that saves the company money.
1. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pCkL9UlmCOE