But this is about Twitter the platform rather than Twitter the organisation isn't it? It's closer to formalising the sort of promo the MacHeist guys do where you get extra stuff for tweeting about them.
I must admit I like the idea as a business. It's limitation is that the more successful it is, the more frequent it's messages, the more spam like it becomes, the more people will hate it and the less successful it will become...
Which is to say that pwat could be totally effective in being a payment mechanism, but only if the stakes of the pwat's message are high enough to equate to a non-trivial reblogging of a url.
If enthusiasm isn't authentic .. who's going to take notice?
If the generated buzz isn't actually generating interest organically, then this scheme is just about link building .. which is equivalent to spamming imo.
And, even if some rooks do not have that understanding, it will not ruin things for those of us that do, because we will unfollow them.