Sure they can: the federal government could just add a provision to copyright law stating “the distribution of the unmodified text of any standard referenced in and necessary to assess compliance with, or otherwise determine the applicability or effect of, any law, regulation, or other binding act of any part of the federal government, any state government, or the government of any subdivision of a state, shall, in all cases, be considered fair use.”
Whether they should is another question.
> Along these lines, can the SDOs continue to make money on derivative goods such that they have an adequate incentive to continue producing these standards? As one amici notes, even after a sister circuit ruled that an organization that drafted a model building code adopted into law lost its copyright, see Veeck v. Southern Building Code Congress International, Inc., 293 F.3d 791 (5th Cir. 2002), its successor organization remains profitable both through sales of codes and of “program services, including consulting, certification, and training.” 66 Libraries Amicus Br. 22 (citing Int’l Code Council, Annual Report 52 (2015))
There is HUGE value in the training materials around proper use and understanding of these standards.
For example, a building standard may specify that a sewer plumbing run must have a 1"/12" slope for proper drainage. The training comes in the form of handling the problem cases and still staying compliant with the standard.
In the accounting field, accounting standards are made and enforced to a large degree by private entities. Staying current requires constant training hours, recertification and in some cases external visits from other accounting professionals.
Keeping them secret to practicioners-only seems perverse. And if they’re expensive, this is the effect.
That’s not necessarily true for every standard, but in general the industry creates the standard because it needs to; the government comes along later and mandates use of standards that have already become widely adopted and time tested.
But the standard should be freely published if it’s a law
I research many more things than I build. It seems bizarre to collect fees from me when I’m researching an idea rather than when I implement it
I'd agree with your last point but only if reworded slightly: "the law should only rely on standards that are freely published." To me, this is where public.resource.org is barking up the wrong tree. The obligation to ensure free access to the law rests squarely with the government. It's not ASTM's duty to allow free access to standards that the government incorporated into a standard. If the government wants to use copyrighted work, it should enter into appropriate arrangements with the standards organizations that produce it.
Yes I agree with your rewording, I would just add that it doesn’t seem difficult to find a solution that satisfies both parties. Of course inertia is the real barrier. The current fee structure was designed when printing books was expensive, and that’s why it seems so obtuse in retrospect.
> The obligation to ensure free access to the law rests squarely with the government.
Equal protection clauses and First Amendment control here. Otherwise there is secret law.
In a degenerate example, "the crime of murder and a proper defense shall be determined by standard 451 from the Bradbury Institute." The Bradbury Institute will be happy to sell a copy of that standard for $100 million.
To use a different example: the government makes a law establishing yor back yard as a polling place for federal elections. Surely, you agree that peoples’ right to vote cannot to be vindicated if they can’t freely access polling locations. But that doesn’t mean that you are obligated to let everyone onto your property! The law is the problem, and the government is at fault for failing to ensure that polling locations are publicly accessible.
The particular constitution clause only permits congress to grant copyright exclusivity if (and to the limits) it wishes to; it doesn't require the congress to grant this exclusive right in any particular scope or even at all - it's up to the congress to decide.
There is no right to vote. So the rest of your case does not apply.
Furthermore, I don't agree at all with your analogy. I feel that it is fundamental requirement to have complete access to the law. So any examples, that result in arguing to the contrary I disagree with up to and including the "taking of property".
> But that doesn’t mean that you are obligated to let everyone onto your property!
This is also not true. The legal concept of "Easement by Necessity" ( https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/easement-by-n... ) applies so once again your example is incorrect.
That would, in many ways, make things worse: you narrow the pool across which payments are spread, thereby increasing implementation costs and reducing competition in any field covered by such a standard.
However in law, the standard isn’t just “a standard”, it’s an enforceable law. And yes, anyone should be able to know what the law is for either commercial, academic, or purely self-educational reasons without paying an arm and a leg.
If there is a rule that governs your behavior, you should be able to know what it is.
Someone has to bankroll these efforts. The way it happens now is that the people who need the standards (the ones building regulated products) are the ones that pay for standardization. Indeed, they might well be ASTM members themselves (the ASTM has 30,000 members, including producers and users).
So you’re asking the public to take on a major expense to vindicate the abstract principle that, if some random person wanted to look up what the standard requires, they should be able to do so for free. That might well be what the Constitution requires. But you can see why nobody wants to do it.