This is fine for things that are apparent to the user, such as "I don't like this popup window, so I'll configure it to not show", or "I want a better command to split a quoted email, so I'll create that function". But in this case it's about something that happens behind the scenes, which users may not know needs changing.
Now that I've had the relevant comment out of the way, let me be a little more general.
> It isn't the Emacs way to second-guess our users' needs
This is an odd statement to make. Or rather, let me say, Emacs has an approach to this that I haven't been able to explain to myself yet.
It is absolutely true that Emacs tends to ship with so-so defaults, and that this is not a big deal because most users will want to change the defaults anyway. It is also the case that Emacs is very customizeable, so changing any defaults whatsoever has never been a problem.
However, the term DWIM, meaning "do what I mean", originated in Emacs circles. It still flourishes there.
I create dwim forms of commands all the time. There is often a simple contextual, environmental indicator as to whether I want one variant of a command or another. Not encapsulating that check and dispatching into a new command would be silly. That's a core part of Emacs and Lisp culture, in my opinion.
So yes, it is also in fact the Emacs way to guess the users' needs. But transparently.
//edit BTW, those aren't my words, those are Eli's responding to Perry
It should generally be possible to predict the range of responses when submitting a patch to a free software project, or when posting to a free software list. If the input is "TLS" and the output is "TSA," it puts a strain on everyone and free software development suffers as a result.
> It is IMO unreasonable to make our defaults match what happens in dictatorships that you describe, because that would unnecessarily inconvenience the majority of the users. Let's not follow the bad example of the TSA (whose rationale is, unsurprisingly, also matters of life and death).
Here's that same response in an alternate Gnuniverse where software development is... different...:
"Thanks, Jimmy. Security is outside my wheelhouse, so let me run your ideas by a security researcher I already know and trust. Then we'll figure out the most effective way to improve TLS in Emacs without creating a maintenance burden for the project.
Best, A sensible developer who knows what they don't know"