Re:A Citizen Is Suing the US for Putting Him on the 'Kill List'
by jonathanstrange on Friday July 20, 2018 @04:28AM
(#17573347)
That's hair-splitting nonsense. Drone victims are very often neither combatants nor suspected combatants but rather local warlords/politicians. In many cases the US forces do not try at all to determine whether the victims are combatants (i.e., whether they are holding a gun in their hands, for instance).
As the article lays out the assassinations are made based on death lists compiled by US intelligence agencies. They can put whoever they like on these lists, in this case they put a US citizen on it, for example. That's the paradigmatic example of political assassinations, and e.g. on a par with what the US did when they supported death squads in Chile, except that in Chile the death squads were mostly comprised of non-US citizens whereas drone strikes are conducted by US citizens.
If they're combatants, it's not political assassination. It's a combat operation.
If they're suspected combatants, it's still not political assassination. It may not be morally justified, but it's not political assassination. (And it still may be morally justified. You almost never have total certainty in discriminating between civilian and combatant, even in a formally declared war against a formal military.)