And in general, I find it difficult to buy your "I don't own a fax machine argument". I don't own a photocopier, but that's a small blocker, no?
Actually, you did provide some context, which is that it was a "demo" account on a personal credit card. This, at the very least, implies much less spending than in the blog post that kicked this all off.
More importantly, what's missing is the human/support response and attitude from AWS, which is the OC's primary concern.
Anecdotally, from the comments I've seen on HN, AWS customers (at least beyond a certain size) seem generally pleased with the availability of human judgment during support issues, especially so when paying for that support.
While this might not strictly apply to some other particular situation, my experience would lead me not to ever trust Google when they say "do this seemingly logical thing because it will make you safer".
Furthermore, this response could be construed as reinforcing the OC's precise concern regarding Google's attitude:
> that you are probably wrong.
As I mentioned above, in this case, WE were absolutely wrong, and the blog post details all the ways we're fixing it.
You did admit error and apologize in the blog post (perhaps not explicitly or early enough in the text for some people, but that's a separate issue), and you specified how you were going to fix it. It may take time for the reputational effects of those fixes to permeate.
That's not the issue.
The issue is that, here, you have, effectively, said, "but the customer could have..".
Even the implication that the customer might share in the blame, no matter how objectively true it may be, takes credibility away from the sincerity of an apology and can easily be seen as evidence of the persistence of same, old attitude. Given that the statement happened after the apology, further time is unlikely to make a difference.
1) This was, in NO WAY, the customer's fault. At all. Not even a little bit. They did stuff that was totally normal for a customer to do.
To remedy us not accidentally flagging totally normal stuff as fraud again, we talked about 7 steps we were taking (that was the first 7 steps in the blog).
2) IF, and only IF, you'd like to take ADDITIONAL steps to avoid us accidentally flagging you, we also offered three steps (at the end of the article). However, these were totally optional.
Hope that helps.
Getting warmer.. but:
Even here, you're saying that the customer has (or could have) some role in preventing your error (accidental flagging). This is merely an issue with the wording (here, not necessarily in the OP blog).
The "protect your account" wording of the blog post itself seems good, as do the specific reasons for each additional step.
My only suggestions would be to add the concept of urgency in reachability to the phone number, as time sensitivity seems to be important to many (but not all) customers, and to substitute something for "don't miss important alerts" (which, again, could be read to imply blaming the customer) that has a more positive wording, that expresses that all the relevant parties would then be empowered to have visibility into those alerts (rather than avoiding the transgression of missing them).
See also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17567900 (which I have no idea as to the veracity of but figured I'd call your attention to)
> Hope that helps.
It does (at least IMO), and I hope you take my feedback in the contstructive spirit in which it is intended. (I don't personally have a strong opinion either way, as I lack enough direct experience).
In our case, we're adding a second human in the loop (we already had one) to double check this. Customers can also add their own human to reach out to by connecting to a sales person (it's free and extremely low pressure!)
---------
Greetings from Amazon Web Services,
We were unable to validate important details about your Amazon Web Services (AWS) Account. Your AWS account has been suspended. While your account is suspended, you will not be able to log in to the AWS portal or access AWS resources.
If you do not respond to us within 3 days of this email (by Saturday, April 28, 2018), your AWS Account, and any data will be terminated.
At your earliest convenience, please send us a copy of a current bill (utility bill, phone bill or similar), showing your name and address. Please provide for both the credit card holder and account holder if different.
IMPORTANT: When you send us your information, please include your email address, so we are able to process your fax as soon as possible. We can be reached via secure fax line at +1-206-922-5831 and 866-437-9072.
Once you have sent the requested documents via fax, please contact us at [email protected] and include the following details:
- The billing address and phone number of the credit card on the AWS account - The billing phone number of the credit card on the AWS account - Business name and phone number (if applicable) - The URL for your website (if applicable) - A contact phone number where you can be reached should we need additional information - Potential business/personal expectations for using Amazon Web Services
If you have any additional information you feel will expedite this process, please feel free to include that as well.
We apologize for any inconvenience this may have caused you and appreciate your patience with our security measures.
Thank you for your immediate attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
Amazon Web Services Team