News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by jhallenworld on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @04:10PM (#17561689)
I find the argument that advanced growing alien civilizations would construct "Dyson Swarms" pretty convincing. These structures have the huge advantage that no new physics is required- we could start building ours now with today's technology.

They would look like infrared point sources. Sadly none detected yet:

https://medium.com/starts-with-a-bang/dyson-spheres-the-ulti...

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by bena on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @05:02PM (#17562031)
Why do you find that convincing?

He pretty much handwaves away one of the biggest problems: material. Saying "we'll harvest Mercury" is such a "world hunger solution"* that I can't take anything further seriously.

*World hunger solution: A solution presented in such a way to seem simple but instead hides many more problems just under the surface. e.g. The best solution to world hunger is to simply give everyone enough food. True, that would solve the problem, but we don't know how to do that.

And saying that "advanced civilizations" will be able to do it is pretty much going into the Giorgio Tsoukalos camp. "Aliens" is not an answer. It still ignores the how. What are the costs of harvesting an entire planet? What are the energy requirements to send mining equipment there, mine the planet, and ship the materials back here to be processed into something useful?

Why do you assume that that level of technology will be cheap and readily available in the future?

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by jhallenworld on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @05:18PM (#17562149)
It's convincing in that it seems physically possible. Even better, it's falsifiable: look for infrared point sources.

Also, what options do you have if you're out of real estate? There is no faster than light travel. Slower than light interstellar travel is certainly not going to be cheap or easy. Of course the other option is for your civilization to stop growing, but who knows if all aliens would go for that.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by bena on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @05:52PM (#17562374)
No infrared point sources just means it's not likely there are any Dyson spheres.

It doesn't tell us why there are no Dyson spheres.

> Of course the other option is for your civilization to stop growing, but who knows if all aliens would go for that.

You act like this is a choice. What if it's not a choice? What if the initial cost to build a Dyson sphere is too great to overcome? Whether in time, material, energy, or another thing. What if it's just not feasible?

Where does that leave you?

You've basically reframed your statement. You find it convincing because you think it seems physically possible. But how? We're just getting to Mars and you think a significant mining operation on an alien planet to be something we're technologically capable of.

We've skipped straight to 3) Profit and forgot to flesh out step 2).

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by eloff on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @08:03PM (#17563052)
It's not profitable yet, or someone would already be doing it. It's something that can be done on small, incremental scales. You don't need to mine a whole planet, that's a strawman. You don't need to build the entire thing, just some solar panels floating in space an attached to something useful (e.g. our communications satellites) fit the bill. It gets more effective the more industry you have in space - we have none so far.

There's no reason to think we won't reach that level of technology - assuming we have a demand for space industry for some reason, like running low of key materials on Earth, or a population that keeps growing.

You're basically just doing that same thing as the OP, claiming "nuh uh" without backing that up either. To which I say "uh uh".

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by bena on Thursday July 19, 2018 @08:58AM (#17565766)
It's an assertion without evidence.

You claim there's no reason to think we won't reach that level of technology. What's the basis for that claim?

> just some solar panels floating in space an attached to something useful (e.g. our communications satellites)

You realize that a lot of our communications satellites already have solar panels attached to them, right?

And you do realize that a Dyson anything is an engineering project that far exceeds anything we have yet attempted. If your plan begins with strip mining a planet 48 million miles away with an army of self-replicating robots, you've obviously skipped a few steps of the process.

Using "science-y" words to describe your pipe dream doesn't make it any less of a fantasy.

I mean, we're still wondering if we can make a car drive itself reliably. That we may not be able to overcome some very basic limitations. And all of a sudden we get to assume we can build a probe that can travel to Mercury, mine it, process the raw material into something useful, assemble those materials into more probes, panels and habitats, then place those bits into orbit around the Sun in a way that it won't get smashed by other satellites, fly off, or get pulled in.

Reducing those concerns to "nuh uh" isn't doing you any favors. You're simply refusing to engage. You're asking skeptics to prove that we will never reach that level of technology rather than answer the question of why do you think we will. You're the one with the actual claim here, back it up.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by eloff on Thursday July 19, 2018 @02:12PM (#17568938)
>You realize that a lot of our communications satellites already have solar panels attached to them, right?

Hence why I said (e.g. our communications satellites), which in English means communications satellites are examples of useful things with solar panels attached "floating" in space...

> And you do realize that a Dyson anything is an engineering project that far exceeds anything we have yet attempted. If your plan begins with strip mining a planet 48 million miles away with an army of self-replicating robots, you've obviously skipped a few steps of the process.

I already mentioned that's a strawman. A Dyson swarm is an orbiting collection of artificial satellites, orbiting the sun. It captures all or a good deal of the energy radiating away from the sun - but it's built incrementally and a single satellite can be the start of a Dyson swarm - so we have the tech now.

> You're asking skeptics to prove that we will never reach that level of technology rather than answer the question of why do you think we will. You're the one with the actual claim here, back it up.

You're deluded if you think you can get random people on HN to defend their statements to a level you'd be happy with. Honestly I don't have the time, and even if I did I don't care.

But since you've got me to engage this far, here goes: we have the tech to build solar powered satellites and launch them into orbit around the sun. So we could start building a Dyson swarm today.

The reason we don't is because it's very expensive, and we suffer a chicken-and-egg problem. There's not much demand for industry in space because we don't build anything in space. The inputs and outputs would have to come from and return to Earth. There's no demand for habitations in space because there's no supporting infrastructure, food, water, jobs, etc. Not to mention the long term health effects of living in space seem problematic to say the least. But it's not unforeseeable that something could change that situation, be it overcrowding on earth, demand for space mining, demand for zero-g manufacturing, space war, government programs, etc.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by bena on Thursday July 19, 2018 @05:09PM (#17570293)
> Hence why I said (e.g. our communications satellites), which in English means communications satellites are examples of useful things with solar panels attached "floating" in space...

What you actually said was:

> You don't need to build the entire thing, just some solar panels floating in space an attached to something useful (e.g. our communications satellites) fit the bill.

Where the implication is that we'd attach these solar panels to something useful and that an example of something useful is the communication satellite. Whereas you wanted to infer that communications satellites were the entire enchilada, a solar panel attached to something useful. Which is also a bit disingenuous as the panel is a part of the satellite, the power source, not an add-on. Which pretty much led to the confusion.

> A Dyson swarm is an orbiting collection of artificial satellites, orbiting the sun.

That's a reduction as to what it actually is. A big part of the Dyson architecture is to capture and use the energy provided by a star. Simply having a satellite orbiting the Sun would not fit the bill.

And a space based solar power satellite does not exist. Because it's more expensive to launch and implement than it would return. All current solar power on satellites provide enough power to power themselves. That's it. What you are asking for is something different.

NASA themselves says that a SBSP satellite is decades away at the earliest. And any proposition to be speculative at best.

And yes, necessity is technically the mother of invention but it can't change the laws of physics. It can't change the cost of what's necessary.

> You're deluded if you think you can get random people on HN to defend their statements to a level you'd be happy with.

This is just a dodge. You've done nothing but say "It's not unforeseeable" and "It's inevitable". You haven't actually provided a reason as to why you think that. I'd be happy with anything more than a handwave in the general direction of the actual issues facing building a Dyson swarm.

> Honestly I don't have the time, and even if I did I don't care.

You do care, you just don't really have any answers besides the blind faith of "technology". Which is no better than blind faith in anything. Believing technology will get better doesn't actually make it better.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by platz on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @08:23PM (#17563147)
We know how to give everyone food. We just don't have the political desire to do so.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by Analemma_ on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @05:31PM (#17562247)
> I find the argument that advanced growing alien civilizations would construct "Dyson Swarms" pretty convincing.

Why? I know it's a staple of SF that, on a long enough timespan, we will surely eventually build stuff like Dyson swarms and interstellar ships, but the more I observe actual humans, the less convincing I find this argument. Even assuming great advances in technology, Dyson swarms will be ridiculously expensive to build, especially relative to the benefits they provide, and human grumbling about costs and taxes will probably kill the project instead.

More generally, given the conflict between "fund and build this highly exotic and expensive thing now" vs. "don't bother, thus keeping taxes low", humans will always choose the latter in the absence of some kind of external motivation beyond "for science!", or even our own survival. Americans only agreed to spend the zillion dollars to go to the moon because we were in a dick-waving contest with the Soviets, and a lot of the necessary technology was already in existence thanks to money spent on ICBMs.

I think it's more likely than not that we will keep kicking the can down the road vis-a-vis the current problems of our population growth, and then just go extinct when they finally catch up to us. Or, even if you're not that pessimistic, that we just stay on Earth because no one wants to bother with the difficulties of going elsewhere. It's totally possible that the same thing happens to most other intelligent species and so there are no Dyson swarms.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by crpearce on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @05:51PM (#17562370)
I think a potential motivation for investing in megascale engineering projects is right there in your comment — military advantage. If humans do manage to colonize other planets it seems inevitable that there will eventually be wars (cold or otherwise) that involve many billions or trillions of people spread over multiple planets or star systems. An ongoing conflict on that scale seems like a great reason to develop a Dyson swarm — we don’t know what kinds of weapons would be involved in a war like that but it’s a safe bet that they require enormous amounts of energy. The first Dyson swarm may well be the result of a dick-waving contest with mass drivers instead of ICBMs.

Just think, a military entity with the population and resources of NATO or the Warsaw Pact would have been totally inconceivable just a few hundred years ago.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by pasabagi on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:08PM (#17562467)
The problem is, a civilization with the kind of industrial base and know-how to build Dyson swarms, if it was still interested in 'military dick waving', would be trivially capable of knocking everybody back into the stone age, or even, totally rendering every planet with a biosphere uninhabitable.

Worse, in such a civilization, it's pretty likely that even small organizations would have the kind of tech you'd need to induce a nuclear winter on a given planet. After all, you just have to crash an asteroid on the right spot, then you have a mass extinction that human civilization would definitely not survive.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by crpearce on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:17PM (#17562510)
Great (and terrifying) point. In that light it would seem that the major blocker for these types of engineering projects isn’t technological advancement as much as advancement in governance/social organization/psychology.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 19, 2018 @12:42AM (#17563959)
Let's not forget about the crazy either. Both those with mental illnesses making them destructive, and those mutilated by the system. Think of the occasional random people going on shooting sprees or bombing runs. Imagine them with access to a home pathogen lab, in 20 years.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by pasabagi on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:44PM (#17562635)
The major blocker full-stop. Adorno once used the V2 flying bomb as a metaphor for our society: as the marriage of total technical brilliance with utter futility and idiocy. I think it's frankly surprising that we didn't blow ourselves up in the cold war. We're extremely developed as technical thinkers, but as social thinkers, half of us vote Trump, and the other half don't have the words to express why that's awful.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by comex on Thursday July 19, 2018 @12:03AM (#17563866)
A civilization with the kind of industrial base and know-how to build Dyson swarms probably also has the ability to create smallish self-sustaining colonies, in space or on/within uninhabitable planets. With enough of those floating around, even if most of civilization was wiped out, it seems likely that someone, somewhere would survive... and potentially be able to reseed a future civilization. So there’s hope.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by canhascodez on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @04:34PM (#17561838)
The SNR to Mars is not great at the best of times. We no longer radiate a great deal of high-power analog signals, because those are not efficient. Space is noisy, digital signals look very much like noise, and radiating to space is not usually the most efficient thing to do if you can avoid it. Our chances of detecting our own planet even from the nearest star would be pretty minimal. Perhaps someone might be able to explain to me why we postulate being able to detect extrasolar aliens.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by Chris_Chambers on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @04:56PM (#17561990)
A Dyson swarm essentially attempts to completely surround a star with solar panels. Infrared wavelengths would then be uncontrollably radiated out into space by the overheating solar panels.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox by canhascodez on Thursday July 19, 2018 @12:44AM (#17563962)
Yes, I'm aware. How many of those do you think you could hide in a ten-light-year circle around Earth, and how long do you think it would be before we were able to find them? To a first approximation, the only things that we can see at stellar scales are stars, and all of the discussions on this topic seem to revolve around detecting radio transmissions. This page[0] gives pretty pessimistic numbers for the maximum SNR to Mars. There seems to be some massive disconnect between what people are looking for and what we are currently emitting, or what we might expect an advanced species to be emitting. And my assumption in these cases is that it's substantially more likely that I am a fool and missing something important rather than that everyone else is.

[0] http://www.astrosurf.com/luxorion/qsl-mars-communication3.ht...