Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox
by whatshisface on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:04PM
(#17563294)
You could go to ten thousand magic shows and write down the result of the card guessing each time. Then, based on those probabilities, you could win on average a betting game between audience members about the results of future tricks. No model required.
But it is human nature to speculate, to have an opinion no matter how unfounded.
Personally, I think the chance of encountering another civilization is exactly [0,1]. Pending data to adjust that range.
The question makes no sense because there is no plausible model: he may willingly decide to guess wrong, for example, or the trick may consist in making you forget the card or any other thing.
Assigning probabilities without a real model is just hubris, no more.