Seems to me the wrong question to be asking. Being in the position where you need to "challenge yourself" (and leaving is one way to do so), shouldn't be a problem, it's just something you need to notice and resolve.
As for the other questions, they are great questions, but you'll only ever find ancedotal answers. The serendipity of how you found the next thing and what it was are the rewards for taking the risk. I usually find the story of how companies or people made themselves far more interesting than what they became.
This post makes a point, but its not to be taken literally.
- Because the opportunity hasn't presented itself.
- Because s/he can't afford to quit a job when her/his spouse has just been laid-off.
- Because the car/house/dental treatment hasn't been paid-off.
- Because those students loans can not be deferred
- Because this company actually pays for the a good part of tuition, and requires that the employee stays for at least a couple of years after graduating.
- Because the person has already left four or five different jobs previously, so it's getting harder and harder to justify to an interviewer why the company should hire someone that can't stay at the same place for more than 18 months