News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sherlock Holmes May Not Have Been a Real Crime-Fighter, b... by newswriter99 on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @10:56AM (#17550099)
There's a lot about Doyle that was atypical. Brilliant mind. But he believed in some pretty supernatural stuff as well. Faeries and the like.

Imagine what you believe in now that will seem fanciful in a century.

Re:Sherlock Holmes May Not Have Been a Real Crime-Fighter, b... by conanbatt on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @11:20AM (#17550285)
I think our period will be jokes about diets.

"The second paleo era"

Re:Sherlock Holmes May Not Have Been a Real Crime-Fighter, b... by ggg9990 on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @11:05AM (#17550157)
Is that weird? Tons of brilliant people through history have believed in God, spirits, and other supernatural stuff.
Re:Sherlock Holmes May Not Have Been a Real Crime-Fighter, b... by indigochill on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @12:57PM (#17551161)
I'm under the impression that brilliant minds tend to come with eccentricity attached. Part of being brilliant (or at least intelligent) is the awareness that much of what we take as fact isn't. For example, it used to be a "fact" that an imbalance of humors caused all diseases.

The corollary is that when you believe something people think is silly, like that faeries exist, they may be wrong. This is particularly tricky with beliefs like this one which are technically impossible to empirically disprove.

Re:Sherlock Holmes May Not Have Been a Real Crime-Fighter, b... by s-shellfish on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @02:01PM (#17551704)
It's honestly easier to just create a bucket labeled 'beliefs' and make your own mental model of keeping track of which things are beliefs and which things are actual fact. You can still pull things out of the bucket and put things into it. It's just easier to manage that way, because you might have to deal with some statements that go from being empirically disproven to proven to disproven to proven and so on and so forth for a long time. Just a consequence of too much information and a brain that can't handle all of it independently.

Being able to trust others in their understanding is helpful but it's probably not going to help you sleep at night trying to figure out what you know and what you don't.

Re:Sherlock Holmes May Not Have Been a Real Crime-Fighter, b... by empath75 on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @11:58AM (#17550582)
It seemed fanciful at the time and he was mocked for it quite a bit.
Re:Sherlock Holmes May Not Have Been a Real Crime-Fighter, b... by SaulOfTheJungle on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @12:12PM (#17550711)
There is nothing supernatural about faeries.
Re:Sherlock Holmes May Not Have Been a Real Crime-Fighter, b... by pacnard on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @12:14PM (#17550736)
Cryptozoology? I still think it can fall into the supernatural somewhat?
Re:Sherlock Holmes May Not Have Been a Real Crime-Fighter, b... by OscarCunningham on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @12:29PM (#17550873)
They're supernatural in terms of literary genre, but in terms of the actual content of the belief there's nothing supernatural about the idea that there could be people much smaller than us (unless you also claim they have magical powers).
Re:Sherlock Holmes May Not Have Been a Real Crime-Fighter, b... by navaati on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @01:33PM (#17551460)
Well no, a major characteristic of a fairy it that it flies, it has insect-like wings in the back.

And I believe that from a bio-mechanical (muscular, skeletal) point of view, insect-like wings capable on sustaining flight are not possible on a human back.

For an interesting take on this, see the Artemis Fowl series of books where fairies don't have actual wings but are much more advanced that us regular humans, and fly thanks to technological winged backpacks, and this is the origin of the human myth of fairies (they started hiding after middle age, thus why the myth stayed intact).

Re:Sherlock Holmes May Not Have Been a Real Crime-Fighter, b... by OscarCunningham on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @01:54PM (#17551633)
That seems to me like a natural argument against a natural hypothesis, rather than a proof that the hypothesis is supernatural.

I guess I'm using a definition of "supernatural" like Richard Carrier's: "mental things [that] cannot be reduced to nonmental things" (http://richardcarrier.blogspot.com/2007/01/defining-supernat...).

So under this definition wizards, psychics, ghosts and gods are all supernatural; but Bigfoot, UFO abductions and fairies aren't.

The Artemis Fowl series is great. Although in the context of this discussion I find it funny that the fairies do have magical powers, it's just that flying isn't one of them.