News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK unveils new Tempest fighter jet by detaro on Monday July 16, 2018 @03:15PM (#17544113)
If you start a manned figher program now you might be able to retrofit autonomy later, otherwise you have a state-of-the art manned fighter.

If you don't and bet on drones, you are betting on uncertain developments in artificial intelligence and the hope that you'll develop a framework in which you can use weapons that make decisions for themselves and are left with your current, then out-of-date planes if you are wrong. And likely spending a bunch of billions in the process as well. Todays mostly remote-controlled drones with some autopilot features are a very different beast from what you'd need to generally replace human pilots.

Re:UK unveils new Tempest fighter jet by closetohome on Monday July 16, 2018 @04:09PM (#17544646)
I think the quality of AI necessary really depends on how you structure the force, and what you're fighting. It's not like they'd be out there doing Top Gun style dogfights. They'd most likely take the role of high-altitude bombing and launching missiles from over the horizon, guided by AWACS.
Re:UK unveils new Tempest fighter jet by detaro on Monday July 16, 2018 @04:53PM (#17545002)
> They'd most likely take the role of high-altitude bombing and launching missiles from over the horizon

Not really a fighter role, which article and parent explicitly talk about (e.g. otherwise "turn harder" isn't a relevant benefit). In other roles partial remote-control is more viable, and less intelligence needed, on the other hand the benefits maybe not so great - maybe cost primarily, once it is figured out? I'd guess a bomber could operate in slightly more dangerous situations and wouldn't need a full crew being trained and paid, but you'd loose flexibility and the crew is likely not a big impact weight/aerodynamics wise.

Re:UK unveils new Tempest fighter jet by roryisok on Monday July 16, 2018 @03:32PM (#17544283)
Ok, fair points. The estimated cost of replacing the trident nuclear deterrent is somewhere north of £25bn so I guess £2bn is "cheap" anyway.

I take your point about uncertainty of AI, particularly in light of growing concerns that self driving cars are a lot further off than predicted.

But in regard to betting on drones being risky, surely betting on old fashioned manned planes is riskier?

Re:UK unveils new Tempest fighter jet by eropple on Monday July 16, 2018 @04:01PM (#17544583)
"Old-fashioned manned planes" work. It's not riskier to bet on the sure thing that has an upgrade path (in the event that drone AI does make the jump, it's not like a modern fly-by-wire plane won't be able to be retrofitted) to the potential new thing.