In addition to the incentive problem, you would also need to get people to peer review any changes to a paper. Most of the changes would be minor and annoying to peer review.
I think that courses remain the best way of distilling and communicating knowledge. The only problem is that they're not always available to a lay audience, since there's little incentive to make them available.
The other alternative for the lay audience is science/economics journalism (Economist, Scientific American, Discover, etc). This works to some extent but mostly just scratches the surface, since even regular journalism is struggling to be profitable these days. With deep technical topics there are too few readers and too few qualified, willing writers.
Re:No Paper Is That Good
by jacques_chester on Friday July 13, 2018 @07:23AM
(#17521965)
I think it's more useful for papers to be what they are: diffs. A textbook is a snapshot view. Both kinds of embodiment are necessary in their native form for different purposes.
It is understandable though. Once the paper is published, then it is no-longer novel, and there is obviously lack of reward and motivation to write the same idea again -- just to write it better. ... unless you are actually writing a review paper, but then, it appears there is little value unless the review is "complete". A good illustration of the idea need be able to high-light the key idea while avoid having minor ideas obscure the key. Therefore, a "complete" review paper rarely provide a good read.
Compared to papers, a good text-book often is a much better read than all the original papers. It is not really because of the size, rather it is because a good text-book is written from the reader's point of view and focuses on conveying the idea itself (vs. selling the idea). And a good text-book takes many rounds to develop.
There is no reason papers cannot be developed in a similar way as text books: once a ground-breaking paper is published, it shall be constantly updated, each new edition reflects what the author has newly learned and incorporating new development including the entire community...
Alas, that is not the culture, and there is no motivation to do such.