I agree with you, I like most of the examples shown that are supposed to horrify you. I like most of the traditional, "good" examples too, but not reflexively.
The points made are reasonable, though, and not the first time they've been made.
Re:Why You Hate Contemporary Architecture
by ahartmetz on Thursday July 12, 2018 @05:56PM
(#17518958)
Yup. I don't like the old hospital because it seems to be made of ornament, which is too much. Some of the modern buildings look nice.
Also, the author seems to be saying that Walter Gropius only created jarring monsters, which isn't true. I'm not sure about him personally, but the Bauhaus, the architecture school he co-founded, produced plenty of pleasant-looking though minimally ornamented buildings. The original Bauhaus stuff looks so much better than the bland stuff that hack imitators created later.
From the pictures in the article, London's "Alexandra Road", the Poydras building, the Tour Montparnasse, and the Caltrans District 7 HQ genuinely look really nice. I would love to live in/near any of those buildings.
I don't understand why the author assumes "clean lines" and "geometric shapes" as being some depression-inducing "sickly" visual. Are things only allowed to look nice if they are wrapped in psuedo-victorian embellishments?