> Architects often get mad when non-architects conflate the terms “modernism,” “postmodernism,” “Brutalism,” etc. They love telling people that, say, “Frank Gehry is actually REACTING to postmodernism.” These terminological disputes can obscure the fact that everything under discussion is actually just a minor variation on the same garbage.
I for one agree with that.
> The article asks which hospital I would rather convalesce in? The ugly squat one with private rooms and plumbing, obviously.
You know this isn't either-or, right? The old building might lack amenities just because of when it was constructed, but you can build new beautiful buildings that have them. There is no reason why modern requirements necessitate godawful buildings.
They're comparing literally hundreds of years of architecture to a short 2-3 decade period following one of the most calamitous wars in history, when Europe was struggling to rebuild itself and function was more important than pretty exteriors.
You know this isn't either-or, right? The old building might lack amenities just because of when it was constructed, but you can build new beautiful buildings that have them. There is no reason why modern requirements necessitate godawful buildings.
Modern requirements don't necessitate godawful buildings, budgets do. In those rare situations where the budget is unlimited (i.e., see any building being built around Mecca), you end up with both beautiful exteriors and functional interiors. But otherwise, every dollar spent on a fancier exterior is a dollar that can't be spent on interior features. And occupants (residents or companies) care more about the interior than the exterior.
Of special note: the opinion piece compares two hospitals. The nicer looking hospital is now a museum and has been for years. The interior pictures of the former hospital's rooms show massive rooms without AC, plumbing, or privacy. The article asks which hospital I would rather convalesce in? The ugly squat one with private rooms and plumbing, obviously. I don't care what the outside of the hospital looks like when I'm in side it.