News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Launch HN: Synthetic Minds (YC S18) – Program Synthesis ... by Animats on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @03:03PM (#17509411)
I'm surprised that YC funded this. The ICO/off-brand cryptocurrency/smart contract fad is kind of over, as yesterday's post on failed ICOs pointed out.

In the "dApp" world, the top five by market cap are:[1]

- EOS, a competitor to Etherium. It's a platform for more dApps.

- VeChain Thor, which pivoted from a RFID tracking system for cargo to a "mobile wallet".

- Tron - "The platform is still in its infancy as is expected to reach the “Eternity” by 2023. In its final stage, the platform will allow content creators to directly monetize their content by creating their own token over the TRX blockchain."

- Omise - this is a "white label solution for mobile payments". It doesn't really use "dApps", it just used a token sale to raise money.

- Icon - a blockchain to integrate other blockchains.

None of these actually do anything.

If this is so great, is YC itself buying ICO tokens? Didn't think so.

[1] https://www.newgenapps.com/blog/top-ethereum-dapps-tokens-re...

Re:Launch HN: Synthetic Minds (YC S18) – Program Synthesis ... by akharris on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @03:26PM (#17509608)
We try to never make funding decisions based on what's currently hot. We invest in founders who we think are excellent and who are building for long term outcomes.

In this case, we've known Saurabh for years (this is the second time we funded him) and I've been talking to him about Synthetic Minds for close to a year. If you believe, as he and I do, that the story on crytpo has barely started, then what he is building will have a huge impact on the future state of the world.

That's a bet we'll take whenever we can.

Re:Launch HN: Synthetic Minds (YC S18) – Program Synthesis ... by saurabh20n on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @04:23PM (#17510003)
I get your concern about the current-state. The "dev/money" ratio needs adjustment. Market cap/ICO/yet-another-cryptocurrency is not what excites me.

I am working on a simple premise: The DAO (perpetually running, globally accessible, democratic kickstarter) would have been a good project to see succeed. It failed not because it was a bad idea, but because we rushed into it without tools like this one. Augur, Aragon, 0x, Golem, Filecoin are other projects that might be worthwhile. Also ZCash (doesn't have smart contracts yet, but you should really look into the work Ariel Gabizon and company are doing.)

You wouldn't want to write an linux kernel code without a compiler, would you? You shouldn't write immutable code without formal verifiers. Agree?

Re:Launch HN: Synthetic Minds (YC S18) – Program Synthesis ... by CryptoPunk on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @03:10PM (#17509465)
Those are the top 5 tokens, not top 5 DApps. While the two are often coupled, they are not synonymous. There are DApps without tokens, and tokens without DApps.

And the fourth item on your list is wrong. It's OmiseGo, not Omise. Omise is the company behind OmiseGo, which is a project aims to develop an Ethereum (Plasma) side-chain to host a decentralized exchange.

Re:Launch HN: Synthetic Minds (YC S18) – Program Synthesis ... by 1996 on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @03:40PM (#17509712)
Typical negative comment when it comes to blockchain technology.

Some people have made millions, some brand new technology is created after a unique technological advancement that solves the byzantine general problem, even YC is investing --- yet old people cry "it is nothing but a fad!", so much that it becomes comical, like the black knight in the Monty Python (especially when it comes from someone confusing Dapps and Tokens)

Eventually, you guys will have to admit you were wrong. A bit like people who thought horseless carriage were a fad. It's ok, we all get things wrong someones. No bad blood.

Technology is here to stay. Many people are ideologically opposed to the libertarian roots of cryptocurrencyes. Many others regret not investing in time, or selling too early.

I get that. But maybe it's time to move on.

Re:Launch HN: Synthetic Minds (YC S18) – Program Synthesis ... by JustFinishedBSG on Thursday July 12, 2018 @05:40AM (#17513228)
> unique technological advancement that solves the byzantine general problem

It doesn't even solve the byzantine general problem...