Re:Argh-P-M – Dissecting the RPM file format (2016)
by RVuRnvbM2e on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @08:48AM
(#17506423)
> I have never had an RPM-using system have its package database corrupted beyond repair
you've had that on Debian?
> rpm fully supports downgrading packages, which is something I have missed on Debian multiple times
Huh? Downgrades are fully supported by dpkg and apt*.
Re:Argh-P-M – Dissecting the RPM file format (2016)
by Subsentient on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @01:35PM
(#17508708)
> Huh? Downgrades are fully supported by dpkg and apt.
No, they aren't. You need to remove the newer version prior to installing the old one. RPM based systems allow you to downgrade to an entirely different distro release with one command.
> you've had that on Debian?
More than once, sadly.
Re:Argh-P-M – Dissecting the RPM file format (2016)
by yjftsjthsd-h on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @11:30AM
(#17507679)
I've had a Debian system break because I couldn't fix the package database, yes. I might well have just missed a trick, but I did google around for fixes and got nowhere.
Re:Argh-P-M – Dissecting the RPM file format (2016)
by CyberShadow on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @11:26AM
(#17507639)
How are these qualities descriptive of the file format and not of the particular implementation of the package manager used by the distribution in question?
Re:Argh-P-M – Dissecting the RPM file format (2016)
by Subsentient on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @01:36PM
(#17508724)
I am talking about the official implementation of the RPM package manager from Red Hat.
Re:Argh-P-M – Dissecting the RPM file format (2016)
by CyberShadow on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @04:23PM
(#17510006)
The file format and the quality of the package manager implementation seem to be rather orthogonal, so I don't understand how your top comment is relevant to the article.
But, let's consider that I have never had an RPM-using system have its package database corrupted beyond repair (you can rebuild it with rpmdb --rebuilddb), and unlike dpkg/deb, rpm fully supports downgrading packages, which is something I have missed on Debian multiple times.
RPM is too complex, but it's also a good format from a reliability standpoint.