Re:Gravwell Community Edition: A Splunk Alternative Built wi...
by madhadron on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @10:45PM
(#17504080)
As a former Splunk employee, I would be really sad to see Splunk's search language enshrined as a standard. It wasn't designed, it grew organically from a set of shell scripts. It has no grammar, and using it effectively is largely knowing a grab bag of special commands that someone hacked on to fix a specific weakness of the language.
Interestingly, you don't need a special language. The relational calculus is isomorphic to the regularity calculus, which, in practical terms, means that SQL is a perfectly good language for Splunk's use case.
Re:Gravwell Community Edition: A Splunk Alternative Built wi...
by bovermyer on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @09:52PM
(#17503836)
Just because it's not API-compatible with Splunk doesn't mean it's a "nonstarter."
Splunk is far from the only way to do what it does.
Re:Gravwell Community Edition: A Splunk Alternative Built wi...
by condiment on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @10:03PM
(#17503886)
I don’t disagree. What I meant was that it’s a nonstarter for replacing any existing installation of splunk, which is desirable for me as an enterprise customer who spends a nontrivial amount of money every year on this sort of tool. There are a lot of obstacles to replacing an existing, effective implementation of a tool, and I listed what they are in the hopes that somebody pays attention.
Re:Gravwell Community Edition: A Splunk Alternative Built wi...
by cthuen on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @11:31PM
(#17504271)
I get what you're saying. I don't think you're wrong. This isn't currently a priority for us but I hope that someday someone builds something like that. That's one of the aspirations of releasing a Community Edition. Our API docs are open: https://dev.gravwell.io/docs/#!api/api.md
I would absolutely love to see a competitor emerge that addressed the migration problem through a compatible search api. Handling other timeseries data like metrics would just be icing on the cake.