News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:99designs: Need something designed (logo, ...)? Crowdsour... by jsmcgd on Sunday April 27, 2008 @04:01PM (#175007)
You aren't making anyone do anything. They choose to participate. If they think it's a bum deal, they don't have to do it.
Re:99designs: Need something designed (logo, ...)? Crowdsour... by Tichy on Sunday April 27, 2008 @08:09PM (#175154)
What ARE they thinking, though? I mean, either they are not thinking, or they should think it is a bum deal?

Some alternatives come to mind, but none compelling in the long run:

- I need to practice anyway (but not in the long run, hopefully)

- I am the best and I will win (ok, maybe you deserve what you get)

- I want to be a designer, but nobody will pay me anyway, so at least I get to do my job for free (= ok, so it is a bum job, but I am a loser anyway, so I can't expect anything better).

Re:99designs: Need something designed (logo, ...)? Crowdsour... by chaostheory on Sunday April 27, 2008 @09:41PM (#175195)
it's like saying that it's retarded to enter a programming contest, which I disagree with

Yeah I do agree that it's best for people honing their skills and experience; and for people living in low-cost places where payment in high value currency is worth it (rentacoder, elance, ...). Hell maybe it's fun for some designers like programming is fun for some programmers. What's wrong with that?

I'm still really confused over what I perceive to be antagonism towards contests (unless you own a mom & pop design firm)...

Re:99designs: Need something designed (logo, ...)? Crowdsour... by Tichy on Monday April 28, 2008 @02:41AM (#175424)
Programming contest: yes, for students it is OK, that point I mentioned ("still need to practice"). After a while it becomes pointless.

"low-cost" places: well, if they want to continue living in low-cost places, sure. But in general, even if you come from a cheap country, why should you be forced to work for little money like that, instead of doing proper consulting?

Doing it for fun: sure, if you have the time... I just think it would probably be more fun to do the same thing for real money and a real assignment. What in the "contest" makes it more fun than working for the client directly?

Re:99designs: Need something designed (logo, ...)? Crowdsour... by bouncingsoul on Sunday April 27, 2008 @04:17PM (#175014)
But I think it's a bum deal. I may not directly be taking advantage of people, but I'm giving people an opportunity to be had. Which doesn't sit well with me.
Re:99designs: Need something designed (logo, ...)? Crowdsour... by mixmax on Sunday April 27, 2008 @06:14PM (#175074)
I don't think you should look at it that way. There are a lot of people out there that would like to give it a go - some do it for fun, some try to get a portfolio together, and some are students trying to get better at what they do. There are many reasons for participating, and not all of them have dollars attached.