News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Role of Personality, Authoritarianism and Cognition i... by pjc50 on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @12:00PM (#17499263)
> To see why thia question is ridiculous: Imagine asking this question to people in Tehran during the Shah. In that case, the “proper authorities” were the western-aligned Shah government, while the “rabble rousers” would be the Islamists. But it was the rabble rousers’ view that was authoritarian.

This illustrates both a problem with trying to retroactively jam events into ideological frameworks, and a tragedy of revolutionary parties. At the time, the Shah's government was percieved as authoritarian - that's why there was a revolution in the first place. But it turns out that the violent overthrow of a government (internally or externally) tends to result in the new government exerting extreme force to maintain its position against ""counter-revolutionaries"". Perhaps the unique thing about the American revolution is that it wasn't followed by a Terror, and the civil war was deferred for another century by interpreting "all men are created equal" to mean "not all men".

Re:The Role of Personality, Authoritarianism and Cognition i... by ameister14 on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @12:13PM (#17499400)
The Shah's government being authoritarian wasn't why there was a revolution. It wasn't a revolution against authoritarianism, it was a revolution against forced westernization combined with religious reform, brutal torture of dissidents, and consolidation of wealth. It replaced these things with more conservative government and theocracy. It did that on purpose-the revolutionaries had that as their goal.
Re:The Role of Personality, Authoritarianism and Cognition i... by ozborn on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @12:44PM (#17499762)
Brutal torture of dissidents and consolidation of wealth played a role for most revolutionary groups, but at the onset of the revolution in 1979 most groups were not looking for a theocracy.

The Tudeh and Fedaian were more important in finishing off the government than theocracy supporters, and even the powerful People's Mujahedin (which was Islamist) did not want a theocracy.

See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iranian_Revolution#Opposition_...

Re:The Role of Personality, Authoritarianism and Cognition i... by ameister14 on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @01:48PM (#17500482)
'Most groups' doesn't mean most people. 99.5% of people voted to make Iran an Islamic republic.

This is really simplifying a complex thing, but I would not make the claim that Tudeh was more important than theocratic supporters and even still, they supported the creation of an Islamic republic and supported Khomeini.

Yes, the MEK was Islamist, but like the other two you mentioned, they were also Marxist. They were directly opposed to the Ayatollah because he usurped their power with the poor and promoted what they saw as a bourgeoisie agenda, securing property rights and free enterprise.