It is more plausible that the number sexual partners follows a Pareto distribution. It is likewise plausible that the economist sought to flatten the Pareto curve, even if this may result in the area under the curve increasing somewhat. Would it work? Maybe not. But this counterexample just reflects badly upon us. Programmers are the new physicists of this era.
If you really want to take the economist up to task, you should find his paper, code his model and parameters exactly, see if you reproduce his hypothesis over a number of trial runs (for all we know, he may not have run a sim at all, given the NYTimes' shoddy reporting).
My model does have a number of flaws (a uniform distribution is still not very good; there's no gender distinction; the transmission rate per encounter is artificially high; people only stay with their partners for a random-yet-uniform amount of time) but I'm not sure to what extent these matter.