Re:Inside China’s Dystopian Dreams: A.I., Shame and Lots of ...
by jacquesm on Monday July 09, 2018 @05:42AM
(#17489058)
Heh, you suddenly made me realize that that old school publishing house may have a role after all: At least now there is some way to distinguish corporate crap from actual science.
Not that all of it is great but at least there is a bar to be crossed. There are some examples of outright fabrication in scientific publishing but the bulk of it seems to be in earnest.
Well, science is a noble aspiration and a great methodology.
A scientist, on the other hand, and "scientific results" in actual practice can be anything, from great, to non-reproducible crap (most papers), to trite BS (lots of papers), to lies and distortions to sell some product, corporate interests, or ideology (a heck of a lot of them).
Just because someone is called a scientist doesn't mean they do science.
Increasingly they work more as "promotional" and/or "support" departments of corporate and government interests.
And the public might be too ignorant (lack of knowledge and terminology) to articulate this properly, but is not so stupid (lack of IQ and/or experience) to be able to tell something fishy is going on.
Not to mention that usually mere technology is conflated with science, and just because we can technically produce e.g. thalidomide, it's assumed to be good as well (because it's a "scientific result"), and it's proponents bad (luddites). Used thalidomide so it's a clear cut example -- one can find many others.
>The biggest abusers of tech tend to be those in power, closely followed by corporations, but the second is happy as long as they make bank, the first as long as they can use it to cement their position in power.
Agree. And their biggest enablers to abuse tech, and their biggest apologists, are scientists, or increasingly, technologists.
After all, they're their employees. It's not like in the 19th century in the UK for example, were scientists could be lords and independently wealthy, and could call a spade a spade. Or like up until the 70s, when it was easier to be a vocal critic and still find a job elsewhere. With the tight grip on tenured positions, and the decline of the scientific job as a status, they are more dependent than ever.