News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by angularcow on Monday July 09, 2018 @03:57AM (#17488635)
Not sure how "TNT, or trinitrotoluene, is a mixture of the seemingly innocent elements carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, and oxygen" made it past the editor. TNT is a compound, not a mixture. And nitrogen isn't innocent, it's notorious for being in tons of explosives.
Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by erikpukinskis on Monday July 09, 2018 @05:14AM (#17488933)
I don’t think your second criticism is fair. Air is mostly nitrogen. Alone it is innocuous.

The fact that it becomes dangerous when processed with other elements is the whole point of the sentence. Your criticism boils down to: “I already knew that.”

Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by danbruc on Monday July 09, 2018 @06:23AM (#17489217)
Air is mostly nitrogen. Alone it is innocuous.

But only because in air nitrogen has already formed molecules of two nitrogen atom. I would guess, it would not be a pleasant experience to be exposed to atomic nitrogen if this were possible. This contrast between nitrogen gas and other substances containing nitrogen atoms really makes no sense, there is just no relationship between the properties of elements and the properties of compound containing those elements, at the very least not in general.

The fact that it becomes dangerous when processed with other elements is the whole point of the sentence.

TNT is not directly made from nitrogen but from toluene and nitric acid which are both not innocuous and the later is unlike nitrogen gas and TNT. But it boils down to the point from before, in chemistry it makes not really sense to relate the properties of what goes into a reaction and what comes out. It might cause just minor changes in the properties but it might also change the character completely. And you can also arrive at the same compound via different routes involving different precursors with different properties. Arbitrarily picking some and comparing them to the product is not meaningful most of the time.

Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by pytyper2 on Monday July 09, 2018 @11:42AM (#17491061)
Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by mathw on Monday July 09, 2018 @04:08AM (#17488682)
However, most people's encounters with nitrogen on a day-to-day basis involve the more or less inert nitrogen molecules making up the vast majority of the Earth's atmosphere, so it is seemingly innocent unless you know about how when you start compounding it with other things it gets all excited.
Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by dogma1138 on Monday July 09, 2018 @07:05AM (#17489368)
Nitrogen goes boom, like the most basic bomb is fuel/oil+fertilizer this should be pretty common knowledge especially considering how common were fertilizer bombs in the US.
Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by afarrell on Monday July 09, 2018 @07:50AM (#17489523)
> the most basic bomb is fuel/oil+fertilizer this should be pretty common knowledge especially considering how common were fertilizer bombs in the US.

In what context would more than 40% of Americans, people who grew up in a society were "and now I'm on a list" is a common phrase, have learned about the means of manufacturing bombs?

What percentage of people do you think have even heard of Fritz Haber?

Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by NeedMoreTea on Monday July 09, 2018 @08:36AM (#17489747)
How about the context of watching the nightly news where it's common to add that the explosion was a home made fertiliser bomb to a report of some amateur terrorist? No need of knowing any additional process, or if there even is any, or have heard of Fritz Haber and his discoveries.

Or just watching a whole selection of Hollywood movies where sacks labelled "fertiliser" are loaded into the van along with an LED alarm clock and detonator. :)

Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by eganist on Monday July 09, 2018 @08:49AM (#17489797)
This still assumes most people are aware of nitrogen's role in fertilizer, ammonia (possibly), etc.
Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by dogma1138 on Monday July 09, 2018 @08:43AM (#17489768)
By being exposed to the news? https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=fertilizer+bomb&num=100&ne...

And add to that the plethora of TV shoes and movies that specifically use "fertilizer bombs" as plot devices.

Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by eganist on Monday July 09, 2018 @08:48AM (#17489790)
Most people

1) wouldn't google that, and

2) wouldn't immediately connect fertilizer to nitrogen or realize from the phrase that nitrogen is one of the key components.

Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by dogma1138 on Monday July 09, 2018 @09:27AM (#17489978)
People don’t need to google it was just to show that fertilizer bomb is a common phrase on the news you can also add nitrogen and bombs and get the same results.

News, movies and tv shows covered nitrogen and fertilizer bombs extensively since essentially all the bomb related terrorist attacks in the US used these.

And again this isn’t about most people this is about a columnist for Popular Mechanics and pop-sci publication they should know better and if they don’t they at least should do research.

Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by pwg on Monday July 09, 2018 @11:59AM (#17491197)
Except that the news always covers it as a "fertilizer bomb" or "fuel oil and fertilizer bomb" without ever going into the details that nitrogen is one of the elements that has a significant play in the explosiveness of the "fertilizer bomb".

And the vast majority of those watching/reading the news, and seeing "fertilizer bomb" as the "name" are not chemists and have zero chemistry background, and therefore are not at all equipped to make the connection that it is the nitrogen in the fertilizer that provides much of the explosive punch of the "fertilizer bomb". At best all they will ever learn is that "fuel oil and fertilizer" can be used to make a bomb, without ever understanding why this combination is explosive.

Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by DiabloD3 on Monday July 09, 2018 @05:23AM (#17488962)
Or you are old enough to remember the first WTC terrorist attack in the 90s where they had a van full of nitrogen fertilizer.
Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by flukus on Monday July 09, 2018 @04:11AM (#17488693)
> And nitrogen isn't innocent, it's notorious for being in tons of explosives.

It makes up ~80% of the atmosphere, it's easy to forgive someone for being unaware of it's explosive potential.

> TNT is a compound, not a mixture

This is at best just needlessly pedantic. In this instance being correct would probably lead to more people not understanding the article.

Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by Jedd on Monday July 09, 2018 @08:44AM (#17489773)
> This is at best just needlessly pedantic.

I disagree.

An article with chemical formulae, discussing melting vs combustion temperatures, ratios of elements within the compound correlating to explosive effects... and they muddle mixture with compound - this is needlessly lax terminology choice.

I don't think the number of 'people not understanding the article' would decrease if they'd used the right word there.

Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by digi_owl on Monday July 09, 2018 @08:07AM (#17489599)
Yeah until i read up on explosives (and other lively substances, hello Derek Lowe) my impression of nitrogen was that of it being the most benign of atmospheric chemicals.

As i have come to understand it, nitrogen gets real frisky when you pair it up with others that can't fill all its electron bonds. This then leaves it a hair breath away from going back to pure nitrogen bonds, releasing a whole lot of pent up energy in the process.

Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by pwg on Monday July 09, 2018 @12:04PM (#17491238)
Yes, this is why nitrogen is a component of most explosives. While it will form compounds it forms unstable compounds that easily come apart. And that separation of the chemical bonds with nitrogen is what provides the immense energy release that makes for an explosion.
Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by ben509 on Monday July 09, 2018 @12:10PM (#17491277)
Note that the parent said "made it past the editor."

Being pedantic is the job of an editor. And, yes, explaining things correctly is hard, but doing so is the entire value proposition of a technical publication aimed at laymen.

That said, PM did say "seemingly innocent" so that part was entirely reasonable.

Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by dogma1138 on Monday July 09, 2018 @05:46AM (#17489069)
Maybe that person shouldn’t write for popular mechanics then? This isn’t about Joe Average this is about someone who’s their job is to do research and write compelling stories.

And there is nothing pedantic about mixture vs compound a compound has chemical bonds which is what allows the explosion to occur as the breakage of those bonds is what releases the energy.

And as far as explosives go then a mixture again has a very specific meaning it means that there is an external oxidizer or a secondary explosive involved which changes the characteristics of the explosives considerably.

Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by pixl97 on Monday July 09, 2018 @08:36AM (#17489743)
Why all the hate nitrogen? Oxygen, that stuff is dangerous.
Re:So Long TNT, There's a New Explosive in Town by kurthr on Monday July 09, 2018 @11:33AM (#17490979)