Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate
by jasonhansel on Sunday July 08, 2018 @06:05PM
(#17486499)
Formal logic can help to reveal unstated assumptions in reasoning. But disputes about these unstated assumptions, which often involve abstract ethical or metaphysical claims, can themselves be even more intractable.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate
by AndrewKemendo on Sunday July 08, 2018 @06:20PM
(#17486594)
In fact this is exactly where formal debates between intellectuals often wind up - on debating fundamental concepts in philosophy or science.
Any debate that has hope of progressing the state of argumentation about [topic] will include agreements on definitions and fundamental premises so they don't get bogged down there.
If only. A lot of intellectuals were trained in argumentation but not formal logic. The number of times I see `a => b` be equated to `b => a` is mind-rending, and that's not even getting into issues of causality.
A while back someone who stayed himself an intellectual posted a contrapositive of a statement as if it were a brilliant insight.
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate
by jasonhansel on Sunday July 08, 2018 @07:35PM
(#17486915)
I'm not sure that getting "bogged down" by such questions is always a bad thing. Often these fundamental issues are, ultimately, the most important.
Agreed. It seems that the single biggest divider are epistemological systems and the ways people choose which to adhere to. That's a debate which I couldn't convince anyone to start yet.
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate
by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @12:05PM
(#17499320)
I'll have that debate. I can't seem to find anyone to get into that either.
My proposal: You write a Medium post with your argument, I'll respond with my rebuttal/response on Medium. That's how the old guys did it, except with letters.