Re:Thanks For Paying Taxes. Here's A Receipt.
by grandalf on Friday October 01, 2010 @04:17PM
(#1748507)
The rich at the time might very well have opposed having to pay the 1% social security tax.
The inception of the program was based on a variety of too good to be true premises, the 1% payroll tax being the most notable, so I interpret the cap more as a symptom of this fantasy... and possibly a consideration of the stigma attached to welfare programs in those days.
Re:Thanks For Paying Taxes. Here's A Receipt.
by anamax on Monday October 04, 2010 @12:24AM
(#1754589)
I understated things a bit - it wasn't just the originators, but SS advocates, at least until recently.
If you want to remove the cap, then either you're willing to pay Ross Perot $500k/year in benefits or you're going to have uncapped taxes and capped benefits, that is, another 15% tax.
Do you really think that rich people today won't object to another 15% tax?
Since benefits are roughly related to FICA, extending the cap doesn't help much. It helps some, because the benefits system is progressive, in that folks who contribute a lot get less return on their contributions than folks who contribute just a little, but ....
The folks who designed SS thought that the cap was essential. Their argument was that SS wouldn't survive if it paid folks like Ross Perot $500k/year in benefits or if it was a tax with no benefits to folks like Ross Perot. The cap means that Perot doesn't get $500k/year but don't care because he didn't put much in.
Are they wrong?