HSA enrollment has been rising by about 2 million people per year for the last few years, and is now at about 10 million people [1]. I'd say it's catching on.
I cannot recommend the HSA/High Deductible combination highly enough, especially for primary care. The difference between seeing an overworked doctor who is paid by insurance and an independent doctor who is paid by you? Night and day.
For anyone in Seattle, I strongly recommend http://www.qliance.com/ for primary care. Monthly fees for unlimited primary care, probably lower than your phone bill. They're cheap and indescribably excellent. (I don't work for them. I'm not associated with them in any way beyond being an extremely happy customer.)
IMHO, the fact that Obamacare did not expand on HSAs shows affordability is less important than control.
I would love to have some tax-free healthcare money to spend, but I cannot guarantee that I will need penicillin, surgery, etc. this year.
I don't want to consign $5,000 to an account with a significant chance that I will simply have to forfeit the money at year's end.
And at least in my state, $5000 is a high deductible--my provider offers a $5000 deductible plan with an HSA. You do end up paying more than $5k out of pocket before hitting the deductible since there's coinsurance and copays and shit like that, but keeping $10-15k in an HSA--knowing you still have full access to that money and it doesn't expire every year (and then perhaps topping it off every so often)--is not a bad plan.
One thing to note, after this year over the counter meds (like ibuprofen) won't be eligible without a prescription, but band-aids still will be so thanks government for making the program less useful.
It didn't catch on, largely because people are used to having relatively comprehensive health insurance from their employers. Until you break the employment/insurance bundling nothing else will budge. And no one who has a job with health insurance wants to break the bundling.