News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Real world analysis of google's webp format versus jpg by ergo98 on Friday October 01, 2010 @10:17AM (#1747075)
Those who don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it. This is a futile effort by Google and will go no where.

If they somehow managed to chop file sizes by 90% or more, it would have a small chance (it still wouldn't be guaranteed, as in the era of CDNs and caching and large pipes, static images just aren't a big concern). Instead they've marginally chopped file sizes in only certain scenarios, while adding numerous new downsides, while actually reducing the feature set.

Are they insane? I'm surprised they actually announced this.

Like MP3, JPEG is good enough unless the improvement of a replacement format is overwhelming. It doesn't have the political baggage of something like h264, so that argument doesn't apply.

More interesting than this silliness from Google are formats that actually bring new and impressive features. I recall that JPEG2000 could do incremental, stallable loading (or maybe I'm thinking of something else), such that as you scaled an image it wasn't loading an entirely new image, but instead was loading incrementally more data to provide the detail for that level. IP stopped it from taking off, but that was actually interesting. This isn't.

Re:Real world analysis of google's webp format versus jpg by VladRussian on Friday October 01, 2010 @03:14PM (#1748219)
JPEG2000 was wavelet based and that was interesting development, compression-wise and feature-wise like you mentioned.
Re:Real world analysis of google's webp format versus jpg by gojomo on Friday October 01, 2010 @03:04PM (#1748172)
Give it 15 years. If it's free and better, then at some point, all browsers and tools will have it as an option. If CPU keeps improving faster than bandwidth, and free codebases keep growing, then an option to create webP on the fly (or downconvert to jpg for older clients) will become effortless.

In the meantime, if early adopters get a slightly better web experience -- that's a win for Google. They want more marginal pressure to upgrade.

Re:Real world analysis of google's webp format versus jpg by ergo98 on Friday October 01, 2010 @04:41PM (#1748628)
The will be no early adopters.
Re:Real world analysis of google's webp format versus jpg by gojomo on Friday October 01, 2010 @04:48PM (#1748655)
Not even Chrome users hitting Google's own websites? At Google's scale, the savings from that alone might pay for the R&D that went into this.