Re:Could jgc.org be monetized?
by dtby on Friday October 01, 2010 @07:56AM
(#1746744)
Just so you know, your HN comment history meant my boss said we could not buy your Catalyst book. I, personally, think your comments are nearly always valuable, but I could not sell it.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I wonder if he'll consider my comment history to be a "buy" or "don't buy" for the apress book then ...
This is a very cryptic comment. Could you please clarify?
It's not so cryptic. We were implementing an API based on using Catalyst. My boss asked if there were Catalyst books I could recommend. I recommened jrockway's. After a review of his HN comments, my boss decided to depend on Internet resources.
It's not complicated. Mixing up your profit-making identity with your being-real identity does not always translate to increased profits.
Wait, to evaluate a 40$ book purchase, your boss tracked down the author's HN account and "reviewed" his comments? Where do you work, some secret service that's afraid of saboteurs masquerading as Perl hackers?
This is exactly why I'm confused. It doesn't seem to make any sense. What exactly has jrockway said that means you can't buy his book about a web framework?
I don't pretend to know his motivations.
My boss has a sense of technical competemce which I do not care to review because he pays me 2.5 boatloads of money. He doesn't want to buy the book? Could not possibly care less. Somebody else might.
Is this the sort of thing that you should say in a forum that you've already admitted your boss reads and makes purchasing decisions based on?
Sure. I'm not trying to sell him any books.
Nor am I. So why are we even having this conversation?
Also, calling my book "profit making" is ... misleading. I wrote it because the community needed a book and I wanted to write it. 3 years of revenue on the book equals about two weeks of my regular job.
Any future books I write will be for the same reason -- because I feel like people will benefit from reading it. You don't write a tech book to get rich.
Fair enough. I'm not pretending to have any great insights here. In fact, it turns out I misread your initial comment, which led to this over-blown thread.
Well, that's 0.03c USD he'll never see.
Unlike others in this thread, did not pretend he would give a crap about 8 books.
Hilarious. This sort of story is worth significantly more to me than the $3 I get per book.
You should buy mst and kd's book, it's much more up to date: http://apress.com/book/view/1430223650
You get THREE DOLLARS PER BOOK?
Who's your publisher? Perl web frameworks are that popular?!
Apparently the $2 that normally goes to typesetting the book in something other than MS Word, and the $1 that pays the editor to not edit my correct grammar into incorrect grammar went directly to me.
Re:Could jgc.org be monetized?
by danparsonson on Friday October 01, 2010 @08:03AM
(#1746753)
What an odd thing to say, particularly in a public forum - jrockway's profile lists an email address; wouldn't direct contact make more sense for this sort of thing?
Not when we're discussing royalties based on public personae.
jrockway and I have no personal relationship. I don't feel any need to create one, certainly not based on not buying his book. I'm just guessing he has more interesting emails from Nigerians with inheritances.