But now the people viewing your ads are the type that are willing to pay for things. The Wall Street Journal isn't free but commands a premium for ad space.
The wall street journal is huge in comparison both in readerbase and content.
Before the charge for pdf version there were a large amount of downloads which bearswithclaws used to appeal to advertisers now he doesn't even release numbers openly on the site so I would assume it went down quite a bit.
Edit: it also gets less traction on hacker news, and comments are far more negative, where before it was praise and discussing the content and quality.
I always looked forward to the beautifully laid out PDF version.