Re:Why I Don't Love Gödel, Escher, Bach
by rspeer on Thursday July 05, 2018 @10:19AM
(#17463418)
Wow, I would recommend exactly the opposite. If you wanted a dry statement of Hofstadter's philosophy, you could read I Am A Strange Loop, but GEB is remarkable for its form, including the dialogues.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Eh, worked for me! YMMV.
I couldn't do the dialogs until I got through the rest. I also enjoyed IAASL a bit more than I enjoyed GEB. Definitely not saying what helped me figure the book out is what everyone should do.
I guess this just goes to show there's a variety of reasons people enjoy Hofstadter's work.
Hofstadter, introducing IAASL, said something like: "I wrote this book because people got so distracted by the form of GEB that they didn't get the point I was making."
My reaction: "I understood the point, I just didn't care about it as much as everything else that was happening in GEB."
Kind of similar to my appreciation of Bach himself, in fact. The content of Bach's compositions is frequently about praising God, which has no particular relevance to me. But the form and aesthetics of Bach are wonderful.