I also don't think the Red vs. Blue framing made much sense. For one thing it's not clear at all how the .jp instances are related to the "Red" servers.
There's an actual question to be answered about whether ロリコン is morally wrong and if so, a harm that should be prosecuted. If reason that ロリコン is appealing is fundamentally the same as 児童ポルノ (i.e. that there are children portrayed), it seems like the moral case against it is very clear. I don't know enough to say whether that's the case. On the other hand there might be more societal harm from banning it than allowing it. At any rate it's not hard to see why one might be troubled by it, and so I'm suspicious of the author's claim that it's accepted without controversy in Japan.
"it's accepted without controversy in Japan."
While not completely true as an absolute, this is close enough to the truth to be a fair statement.
Even some 児童ポルノ wasn't illegal in Japan fairly recently. And like the other Japanese censorship laws, was brought in as much due to a desire to align with Western pressure and laws as due to any moral sense. (I'm not trying to diminish the second aspect here; I'm saying that both were strong pressures to create the law).
Remember that Japanese morals are much more Confucian than Christian. Breaking a law is immoral in Japan in and of itself because laws exist to create harmony and breaking harmony is immoral. So the fact that 児童ポルノ is illegal, and ロリコン is not forms a large part of the opinion of whether it is immoral or not.
Also remember that the Western hatred of pedophilia and child porn is partially Puritanism. We've successfully thrown off the Puritan yoke, but that part of our culture was deeply rooted, so rather than disappearing, some of it has transferred over to perversions that it's still acceptable to demonize, namely pedophilia.
And I think the Confucians have it right on this one. Pedophilia and child pornography is one of those things that needs to be banned and made illegal for social harmony reasons, and practicers of softer forms of it like ロリコン should be marginalized. Different from, but mostly compatible with the somewhat commonly held opinion that pedophiles are "sick, not necessarily evil".
The wording here implies that we shouldn't be demonizing things like pedophilia, or that somehow, we needed Puritanism to realize that we ought to be demonizing pedophilia, or that this is purely a western construct. Puritanism has just lead westerners to demonize sexuality in general.
For westerners, lolicon is no different than child pornography. And lolicon is still controversial even within Japan.
We should demonize those who act on their pedophilia, not the majority of pedophiles who successfully hold it inside.
The legal and moral justification for banning images of child porn is that distribution encourages production, and production of it is dangerous to real children.
This is a second order effect that's already somewhat debatable (does getting rocks off to porn cause fewer paedophiles to try and sate their desires in the real world, thus lowering abuse rather than raising it?), and it's therefore not entirely clear there's a strong moral or legal justification for banning cartoons or pure text, i.e. trying to ban people imagining child porn. For all we know, if it's true that paedophilia is caused by some sort of brain condition (and why would it be false), then these things could actually be helping children rather than hurting them.
I don't agree with you there and I don't think the author is being insincere. The problem with child pornography is the harm, or potential for harm, of children. Why would you care about a person's motivations as a root issue?
So I think that's the root cause of the "disgust" for this type of art and the motivations behind it; it facilities dishonest use of power.
Anyways, these are just my musings on the matter. I am not an expert or familiar with the subject at all. I just was curious as to why society still is disgusted by child porn even when the harm is removed
> It's not just the harm to children that people have problems with,
then "people" sounds like "most people". Now I don't know what most people feel like, but at least for me and OP, harm to children is what we have problems with. Desire for power, not so much.
(Obviously, just musings from my side as well. Disgust for child porn when harm is removed happens to be one of my pet peeves - I believe that it is easier for people not to act on their desires if they are able to discuss them with others without being rejected by society.)
See http://www.moralfoundations.org
The theory seeks to explain why people can disagree on things while still being sincere
ロリコン - artificial images representing children or child like people in a sexual context, either drawn or rendered with software
児童ポルノ - photos of actual kids in sexual contexts
These online storms in teacups are rarely worth it, but this one is actually quite interesting.