Re:Carnegie Mellon Admission Levels Field by Eliminating Dem...
by wastedhours on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:01AM
(#17450760)
> self-driven initiative?
How much "self-driven initiative" is actually self-driven though when it comes to a formal application process, and not influenced by someone in an advisory role? E.g. a parent who's been through the application process, or a careers advisor in a school (if you're lucky enough to have access to either)?
But how does that in any way go along with shunning "supplementary submission of materials, including resumes, research abstracts, writing samples, multimedia demonstrations of talents, and maker portfolios." How is work (most of which, like a writing sample or resume, requires no resources or affluence to create) less equal than academic records which are literally determined by what neighborhood one lives in? Essays aren't bad in theory, but it's only a matter of time before entire books are written by "admissions counselors" on exactly what influential people to name drop and what "shared values" with the school to highlight. Beyond a basic capability (prerequisites) and a lack of contrary evidence (ex. failing classes repeatedly), what could possibly be a better discriminator of student success then the interest they demonstrate through actual self-driven initiative?