Re:Carnegie Mellon Admission Levels Field by Eliminating Dem...
by wastedhours on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @10:20AM
(#17450376)
It's worth being said that "rich/poor" (or, socioeconomic diversity) is usually a diversity metric HE is also tracked on, so it'd be rare to see an organisation take a stance that would also negatively affect that.
Contextual recruitment (which they say they're moving to), is the current industry best practice in this regard of looking at the issue across most of these factors, so not sure it's favouring one characteristic over another.
Re:Carnegie Mellon Admission Levels Field by Eliminating Dem...
by forapurpose on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @10:19AM
(#17450358)
> I'm reading this as a diversity play, not a rich/poor play
Is there a factual basis for this reading?
Re:Carnegie Mellon Admission Levels Field by Eliminating Dem...
by mdorazio on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @10:32AM
(#17450479)
I'm not sure what you're asking. It says multiple times in this press release that they're trying to increase diversity. It leads with the first sentence "The mission of Carnegie Mellon University includes the cultivation of a diverse community." and then follows with "The goal is to provide a more equitable, level playing field where all segments of our applicant population have the same opportunity in the admission process."
They want diverse students, which includes poorer students, but also includes underrepresented demographics (looks like male/female split is 55/45, and hispanic/latino and black numbers are small).
Basically, I'm reading this as a diversity play, not a rich/poor play. Whether it will actually work or not is another question that's hard to answer without seeing their data. I can pretty much guarantee that on the male/female side, though, demonstrated interest massively favors male applicants. Female students just aren't encouraged to do (or maybe don't have as much interest in) the kinds of things that impress admissions committees in that category, regardless of what they may end up wanting to study by the time they graduate.