Re:The Importance of Having Your Pain Be Legible
by fossuser on Monday July 02, 2018 @06:09PM
(#17445791)
I'd guess this has something to do with if a bunch of men die in the tribe it doesn't matter too much, but if a bunch of the women die in the tribe that's the end of the tribe.
Men are pretty expendable when it comes to what's required to reproduce - that mixed with fighting for status/high risk behavior being attractive probably complicates things.
Re:The Importance of Having Your Pain Be Legible
by belorn on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @09:51AM
(#17450147)
The idea that its a privilege to be viewed as "pretty expendable" is to me a rather odd. In any war where a minority group is used as an expendable meat shield, I have never seen anyone argue that its proof that that minority group holds power and carries "-actual advantages-" in society. In contrast, when some individuals of a category holds power while others are viewed as expendable it indicate that that categorization (ie, this one based on being male) is a poor predictor for privilege.
Re:The Importance of Having Your Pain Be Legible
by fossuser on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:26AM
(#17450947)
That isn’t my view?
I just suspect it’s a component of why cultures tend to protect women in disasters.
Re:The Importance of Having Your Pain Be Legible
by ciphergoth on Monday July 02, 2018 @06:42PM
(#17445990)
This is a group selection based argument.
Re:The Importance of Having Your Pain Be Legible
by petermcneeley on Monday July 02, 2018 @06:49PM
(#17446033)
Excuse the obvious plug. Here is my article on why I disagree with Pinker's attack on group selection. http://darkcephas.blogspot.com/2018/01/on-group-selection.ht...
Re:The Importance of Having Your Pain Be Legible
by haberman on Monday July 02, 2018 @07:11PM
(#17446137)
It seems that altruism can be explained without resorting to group selection. Statistically speaking over history, your group is overwhelmingly likely to be your kin. So gene selection / kin selection seems sufficient explanation for the evolution of group-altruistic behavior.
At the massacre of Katyn, an estimated ~22,000 men and exactly 1 woman were executed by the Soviets.
The West has undeniably patriarchal elements of its history. But trying to spin this into a narrative of pervasive misogyny ignores the very real value that society places on the well-being of women. Even in your own example, the men angrily avenge the treatment of the women by outsiders.