(As mentioned elsewhere in this thread, I go into a bit more detail here: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/theworldpost/wp/2018/02/... )
Will try to write a HN friendly tldr/update soon.
Apple could single-handedly launch a "verified video" system.
Please build this.
— everyone
And in order to implement that, you'll be talking to people who'd sign a video by getting a pen, some paper, and a flatbed scanner.
I'm not entirely joking. My point is that this proves that there comes a point in every field where technical illiteracy goes from being annoying for you (you can't use the best tools anymore, and your workflow is now sub-par) to annoying for others (you can't collaborate effectively) to completely unworkable, as when your work product is now worthless because you can't demonstrate it isn't a cheap forgery. And some people are just not technical, through stubbornness or otherwise. This transition will hurt.
Maybe tools will follow the demand. I'm not entirely sanguine.
Start with something naturally unfocused and exists only as a one off original, and it would be extremely hard to disprove without comparing it to other video of the same event.
The worst solution is to panic and attempt to ban technology like this insuring that only the bad actors will use it.
I want everyone down to kids to be able to make fake videos to their little heart's content so we can all internalize this inevitable Black Mirrorization of reality.
And your proposed solution is fantastic BTW. Unfortunately, there are more than enough bad actors among us to social engineer those signatures out of otherwise trustworthy agencies and a general lack of intellectual curiosity on the part of most people to even bother to check for such things. Imagine the day we have a video where HRC confesses to the pedophile colony on Mars and coming up next, Trump tells everyone where he buried the bodies, and if people look, there will be bodies there (never mind that they're stolen cadavers). How will people cope with a world like this?
It is almost like we need pop art and pop culture to drive this point home before political mass media does it in the worst possible way.
Agreed, but I think it's been long proven most people do. People hear what they want to hear. Maybe that will change, but I'd say it seems unlikely at this point.
| he worst solution is to panic and attempt to ban technology like this insuring that only the bad actors will use it.
Very true.
| I want everyone down to kids to be able to make fake videos to their little heart's content so we can all internalize this inevitable Black Mirrorization of reality.
Increasingly getting there. It only takes one person to make a nice GUI, post it to github.
| How will people cope with a world like this?
Probably poorly if history has taught us anything.
| It is almost like we need pop art and pop culture to drive this point home before political mass media does it in the worst possible way.
Very intriguing. Traditionally, art and culture change as a reaction to current affairs, as opposed to a pre-emption. I'm not sure how to pragmatically flip that paradigm.
However I'd hope that we move to some agreed standard of signing of videos, so their source can be confirmed by the player. It doesn't matter if that source is the bbc, washington post, alex jones, national enquirer, the onion, or "Bob Joe Billy-Bob the Third", it means you know where the video came from, and can trust (or not) it based on that information.
A video with a bbc banner showing the president saying something could easily be faked. One that is signed by the BBC will only be fake if the BBC itself is publishing it as a fake, and that comes with a reputational impact.
Sites that reversion that video (recompress it etc) can simply sign it by themselves. They could claim that they took an original BBC item to do it, and then it's how much you trust that site.
People see someone, be it Donald Trump, or John Simpson, or Walter Mondale, and instinctively know that person said what they can see. That's changing, and it's going to be a long time before our brains change. Even now, you read some rubbish that you consciously know is rubbish, but part of it lodges in your subconcious and affects your thinking down the line. At least if you know who created the video, it gives you a fighting chance.
With this system anyone can still publish, even anonymously, but reputations are hard to gain and easy to lose. I don't like the daily mail, but I know if they publish a video of Obama saying "Killmonger was right, and President Trump is a total and complete dipshit", I'll probably believe he did. If he didn't, that will come out, and the daily mail is off the list of sources I trust to not make crap up (rather than just bend things), and it makes it far easier for reasonable people to dismiss it.
This moves the onus on news sources to be more discerning in their facts, but if they get it wrong then they lose their readers. By signing the news, they are backing it with their reputation. If Alex Jones has signed it, then he's putting his reputation on the line (if he has any reputation for saying something).
Nobody cares much about the reputational impact. Fringe tabloid fake-news, and mainstream 'fake'-news gets plenty of viewers.
BBC itself has manufactured video 'evidence' during the Libyan war. [1] Yet, most people think it's an accurate source of news.
[1] Their 'live broadcasts' showed video of people in India waving the Indian tri-color, which the BBC has claimed was rebels in Libya's Green Square waving the old Libyan tri-color. But, eh, who cares about honesty - when you've got a politically sensitive story to tell.
CBS and Dan Rather takes documents months before the 2004 election [0] and Rather still have 400k+ twitter followers. Even BBC didn’t cover the Iraq War properly when we really needed it to [1].
I read news for opinion and some awareness. But I’d trust a video of Trump strangling a hobo about the same from BBC as TMZ and would need a lot of verification.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killian_documents_controversy [1] http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/3890821.stm
Will the government be in the business of commenting on the veracity of whatever video(s) they anticipate coming? And if they say it's fake (or real), will the public believe them?
Or perhaps active tattoos that display private key signed messages that describe what they’re saying and doing.
I bring you no solutions. Our best programmatic tool for these kinds of video analysis is currently the exact same technology that enables it in the first place. Furthermore, any neural network that can detect fake videos will only be used adversarially to train a better deep fake creator!
The only solution I see is the camera somehow cryptographically signing the video, and enabling users to easily check whether the signature is valid. However I don't think this is feasible, due to the amount of cooperation we'd need between camera makers and video distribution platforms, especially since it's not really in the businesses direct line of best interest help.
The world's going to start getting real surreal.