When I was in SF for tourism a few years ago, it was a complete non-starter even though at a glance it seemed like the most promising option.
That's intentional - http://www.sfexaminer.com/transportation-officials-halt-fund...
It is around $150 a year in the Bay Area right now which makes it very economical if you can take the bike instead of the subway or a bus (i.e. just replace six bus trips per month.)
If only more people felt that way. But look at how many are too lazy/selfish to put away their shopping cart and leave it in a parking spot or propped up on a curb. Even though the docking stations are always close by in that case.
I realize there are also advantages to dockless (you don't have to walk the last bit when near your destination and maybe the bike is nearer to you when you start.)
These are just some ways in which using a dock are more convenient.