Re:Thomas Bayes and the crisis in science
by gweinberg on Sunday July 01, 2018 @10:47PM
(#17439013)
There's probably some truth to this. But if statisticians weren't able to convince the academic world that arbitrarily setting a "statistical significance" threshold is a gross misuse of statistics, then what good are they? It would be like MDs failing to convince the rest of the medical community that bloodletting isn't a universal cure for whatever the hell ails you.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Thomas Bayes and the crisis in science
by smallnamespace on Sunday July 01, 2018 @11:03PM
(#17439064)
Responsibility in communication is a two-way street, and also depends on incentives and relative power.
- Are security researchers grossly incompetent for failing to convince the IT industry to adopt best practices?
- Are voters in democracies grossly incompetent for failing to police their politicians and keep them honest?
- Are media outlets grossly incompetent for not squeezing out 'fake news', whatever your definition?
- Are epidemiologists and public health officials grossly incompetent for not convincing anti-vaxxers of their foolishness?
Anytime there is a breakdown in communications, both the listener and the speaker should probably shoulder some of it.
Re:Thomas Bayes and the crisis in science
by Bromskloss on Monday July 02, 2018 @10:06AM
(#17441717)
> statisticians weren't able to convince the academic world that arbitrarily setting a "statistical significance" threshold is a gross misuse of statistics
What would the proper use of statistics be? I believe it is to produce a Bayesian posterior probability distribution, but that wouldn't be the opinion of a frequentist.