News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by tptacek on Thursday September 30, 2010 @12:27PM (#1743810)
So, I agree with you about all of this, but it's simply orthogonal to the discussion. We are not charting a course in a vacuum, based on pure competing principles.

People have been arguing for the urgency of migrating to IPv6 for over a decade now. Not in the abstract. A decade ago was 2000, and in 2000, people were also seriously concerned about IP address depletion, and certain that we needed to imminently migrate to IPv6.

So the first thing you want to address in this argument is whether or not the Internet --- or, more precisely, the value propositions and service model of the current Internet --- is going to collapse if we don't migrate. And, no, it turns out, it's not going to collapse. It will surely be more expensive for a Fortune 100 company to hold on to a vanity /8, but most of us aren't going to notice any change in a market-driven allocation world.

To me, it follows from this that if we're going to have a usable IPv4 Internet for the foreseeable future, we have a choice:

* We can pursue IPv6 with all vigor and alacrity, forklifting out every piece of software that treats an IPv4 address as a number instead of an opaque bundle of an arbitrary number of bits, or

* We can reconsider whether a constituency in a persistent entry in the global BGP4 routing table is what it means to be a "first class citizen" of the Internet, and instead build a new city on top of the ruins of the old one, relegating IPv4 addresses (over time) to the same trash heap as MAC addresses. This isn't a pie-in-the-sky idea; CDNs and cloud providers are an immediate half-step in that direction, and overlay networks are a reasonable architectural goal for the next 5 years.

In our overlay future, we get more than just expandable addressing; we get multicast service models (which IPv6 isn't going to provide), we get true multihoming (which IPv6 isn't going to provide), we get first-class peer-to-peer routing (which IPv6 isn't going to provide), and we get ISP portability without any intervention or agreement by a nationwide telco or MSP.

There are no comments on this comment yet.