News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bill to End Patent Office Validity Challenges Introduced ... by jcranmer on Sunday July 01, 2018 @01:13PM (#17436437)
Okay, what does the bill actually do?

1. Switches the US back from first-to-file (which is the norm in literally the entire rest of the world) to first-to-invent. This is something that sounds like a good idea, but in practice ends up being more bureaucratic hassle than any sort of actual improvement.

2. Repeals inter-partes review, i.e., a means to assert "this is a bad patent." Note that SCOTUS decided in April that inter partes review is in fact constitutional, so I assume this is basically a change of tactics of litigators from "try to get SCOTUS to rule it unconstitutional" to "try to repeal the law."

3. Eliminates fee diversion. I don't know the law well enough to understand what exactly it's trying to do here.

4. Overturn most of the recent SCOTUS §101 decisions of the past decade (e.g., Bilski, Alice). It's debatable if this is actually possible, though--these decisions didn't rest on "well, they're not actually authorized by law" as much as "it's been well-agreed by common sense that these things can't be patented."

5. Explicitly declares patents as "private property rights." This calls into mind the argument in Oil States, that the government can't revoke these kinds of rights without means of a court (which, if they had been private rights, would have made inter partes review unconstitutional). But I again wonder if it's actually within Congressional power to make this kind of declaration.

6. Stops patent applications from being published automatically. Because publishing patent applications creates prior art, and that would retard innovation. No, seriously, that's the literal argument in the text of the bill itself.

7. In legal cases, the defendant would now have to argue that the patent is invalid, that each individual claim is invalid (even if the claim depends on an invalid claim), and that a permanent injunction is not appropriate, even if the patent owner doesn't make its own patent.

In other words, this bill attempts to undo every aspect of patent reform in the past decade, both from SCOTUS and from Congress. I can't think of anyone who'd be happy about any of this, save for patent trolls.

Re:Bill to End Patent Office Validity Challenges Introduced ... by monochromatic on Sunday July 01, 2018 @01:33PM (#17436535)
> these decisions didn't rest on "well, they're not actually authorized by law" as much as "it's been well-agreed by common sense that these things can't be patented."

By their own terms, these decisions purport to be based on the statute section 101. The Supreme Court rarely if ever bases a decision only on what it considers common sense.

If the text of 101 changes, there’s no reason to think the caselaw that’s grown up around it would stay valid.

Re:Bill to End Patent Office Validity Challenges Introduced ... by jcranmer on Sunday July 01, 2018 @02:03PM (#17436686)
I haven't read the opinion of Alice directly, and it's been a long time since I read Bilski, but my recollection is that both of them turn on "it's long held that some things can't be patented as a matter of nature, and this patent is an example of something that falls into that category." There are things that Congress can't do, and given that SCOTUS is very likely to have an originalist rather than a legislative intent majority, the framework for analysis is very likely to be "what would an 18th century lawyer say about this?" rather than any amount of exhortation about how this is necessary to promote the progress of science and useful arts.

I'm not sure about the exact interplay of different kinds of law here, and I'm certainly not an expert in any variant of law. That's why I pointed out that the legislation might not have any actual effect as opposed to saying that the legislation will not have an effect.

Re:Bill to End Patent Office Validity Challenges Introduced ... by monochromatic on Sunday July 01, 2018 @06:56PM (#17438159)
Well regardless of the statutory interpretation tools employed, they purport to be interpreting section 101, not the constitution. If 101 changes, those cases should be out the window.
Re:Bill to End Patent Office Validity Challenges Introduced ... by shawn-butler on Sunday July 01, 2018 @03:43PM (#17437177)
>> 3. Eliminates fee diversion ....

The USPTO is one of the few agencies of the US federal govt that are profitable. Congress diverts the funds away from the USPTO funding its own improvements (more examiners, better technology, etc) to unrelated programs.

Your analysis of the other points doesn't match your conclusion.

Re:Bill to End Patent Office Validity Challenges Introduced ... by jcranmer on Sunday July 01, 2018 @04:01PM (#17437265)
I didn't comment on the fee diversion because the text in the bill is a series of line edits to the appropriate section of the US Code, which means I'd have to go dig around the whole law to figure out what it was actually doing.

As for the rest of it, I summarized the actual content of the bill itself. (It's only 26 pages, it's not that long). The bill explicitly refers to repealing the 2011 patent reform. It also explicitly refers to displeasure with the Alice and Lexmark rulings, and the entire bit about private property rights is clearly an attempt to overturn the recent Oil States ruling, even if not mentioned by name. There can be no doubt that the bill is trying to roll back patent reform.