Re:Editor of HTML5 questions need for alt text in movie post...
by isleyaardvark on Thursday September 30, 2010 @10:21AM
(#1743325)
I can not only imagine cases like that, I've encountered those cases. Picture a blog with multiple embedded videos, presented without comment.
Navigating their way there gives them context to what the video will be (in the use case that the video is on a blank page). If the page contains textual content then the user will get context from the text. If the video is completely unrelated to location context or to page-level context then the content will be of little to no interest, so providing an alt description adds no real-world value.
Also note that unless the video has audio captioning then the entire video is of little to no interest. Imagine watching something like Lost in Translation with no visual input and no descriptive captioning.