That is NOT questioning an assumption. He seems to imply that blind users have no use for an information that is interesting to other people.
Would you be interested in description of image representing video if you could get description of the actual video?
— I watched a funny video!
— Cool! What was on the poster image?
Poster images for videos are also part of journalistic publications, where the poster also works as a still image and conveys meaning or illustrates a point of the story.
> The image given by the poster attribute, the poster frame, is intended to be a representative frame of the video (typically one of the first non-blank frames) that gives the user an idea of what the video is like. (http://www.whatwg.org/specs/web-apps/current-work/multipage/...)
The plan seems to be that <track kind="descriptions" src="desc.en.srt"> be used as a child of <video> to provide descriptions in sync with the audio. http://www.whatwg.org/specs/web-apps/current-work/multipage/...
Ian's often repeated naive-sounding "Why would you do that? What's the use case?" has shot down many feature requests that seemed good in theory, but weren't that useful in practice.
Perhaps description of the video makes description of poster redundant? Maybe one can use ARIA? Maybe media framework can extract description from the video file?
Even if there is a way to describe the poster, will authors actually care to do it? Will they ignore it (naively assuming blind users don't watch videos) or fill it with boilerplate?