News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Editor of HTML5 questions need for alt text in movie post... by wccrawford on Thursday September 30, 2010 @07:24AM (#1742913)
I'm not surprised that he has trouble understanding that. The 'meaning' of the poster frame isn't clear from that conversation. Does he want a description of what's being displayed in just the poster frame? How does this differ from the title of the video?

For example:

Title: Cat jumping on bed

Frame: Image of cat jumping towards bed

Video: Cat jumps toward bed and lands on it.

The vast majority of the time, the poster frame isn't going to be different than the title of the video.

Now, I agree that when it is different, there should be a way to specify an alt text for it. But to require it when it's the same as the title seems silly to me.

Re:Editor of HTML5 questions need for alt text in movie post... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday September 30, 2010 @09:11AM (#1743116)
>But to require it when it's the same as the title seems silly to me.

Isn't the problem there that one doesn't know it is the same. Requiring a description of the poster image, which can be blank as for alt-attributes of non-content images, means that it clearer when the author has simply chosen not to bother attempting to be accessible as opposed to the poster having no useful content beyond the title.

Re:Editor of HTML5 questions need for alt text in movie post... by mwilcox on Thursday September 30, 2010 @08:10AM (#1743004)
That's not really a very good example, as many videos are far more complex than that.
Re:Editor of HTML5 questions need for alt text in movie post... by bapadna on Thursday September 30, 2010 @08:36AM (#1743053)
To use a non-hypothetical example, right now I'm watching a series:

Title: Dexter. Description: A likable Miami police forensics expert moonlights as a serial killer of criminals who he believes have escaped justice.

The exact episode also has those attributes:

Title: My Bad. Description: In the aftermath of last season's chilling finale, Rita's death has left Dexter feeling responsible, possibly even...guilty. Unable to deal with the trauma, Dexter makes a drastic decision that will impact everyone around him. Quinn stirs up trouble at the station when he notes that Rita's murder, which is being pinned on the Trinity Killer, doesn't fit his normal murder profile. Things get even more heated when Quinn suggests to LaGuerta that they look at the husband: Dexter Morgan. Meanwhile, Quinn offers Debra much needed support, causing her to see Quinn in a new light.

----

Simply put, titles and descriptions are not the same thing. It seems silly to me that somebody would advocate that they should be treated as the same thing just because there is overlap when the content is a 15 second video of a cat.

Re:Editor of HTML5 questions need for alt text in movie post... by pornel on Thursday September 30, 2010 @09:49AM (#1743240)
Your descriptions describe video, not poster frame.

The issue is only about describing poster frame of the video (a placeholder picture that is displayed before user hits 'play').

Re:Editor of HTML5 questions need for alt text in movie post... by bapadna on Thursday September 30, 2010 @10:31AM (#1743355)
Poster frame for the episode:

Title: Dexter - My Bad.

Description: Dexter stands in a dank, dirty, dimly lit public bathroom, gripping a fishing anchor, a malevolent look in his eyes.