News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN:Transitivity property of real numbers

Hello HN,

The transitivity property of real numbers says if a>b,b>c then a>c.but when i test this property with real numbers it give's me false results.let a=1,b=2 and c=3 then the transitivity property says if 1>2,2>3 then 1>3 which doesn't make any sense.i'll be glad if someone could comeout with a nice explanation.

( 5 comments | 3 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN:Transitivity property of real numbers by Kliment on Thursday September 30, 2010 @04:30AM (#1742648)
Well, it's very simple. The "if" is the key to it. IF 1 were greater than 2 AND 2 were greater then 3, THEN 1 would be greater than three. Since neither 1>2 nor 2>3 is true, 1>3 is not required to be true by the transitivity property. If I am taller than you and you are taller than your mother, then I am taller than your mother. If either of the assumptions is broken, the conclusion does not hold.
Re:Ask HN:Transitivity property of real numbers by pencil on Thursday September 30, 2010 @04:45AM (#1742675)
ah.that's a wise explanation .i even realised that it's just a fundamental law and not a theorem.anyways you made it clear.
Re:Ask HN:Transitivity property of real numbers by wingi on Thursday September 30, 2010 @03:09AM (#1742532)
You can only infer something from something true.
Re:Ask HN:Transitivity property of real numbers by btilly on Thursday September 30, 2010 @03:40AM (#1742576)
Start with two false assumptions, draw a false conclusion. Where is the problem?
Re:Ask HN:Transitivity property of real numbers by pencil on Thursday September 30, 2010 @04:21AM (#1742631)
ya you may be right...let me do some research on real numbers and it's properties and then get back to you!!!!