Re:Dangerous Optimizations and the Loss of Causality in C an...
by Contero on Thursday June 28, 2018 @02:08PM
(#17419165)
Yeah re-reading the wording now I think you're right. It's this part that throws me off:
> could determine that, in the absence of any undefined behavior
"could determine that" based on the code example shown
vs
"could determine that" based on static analysis performed on some preceding code
It would have been a lot easier to wrap my head around if it were an example where cond could be 0 or 4 or something along those lines. It would really underscore the compiler's desire to reuse the cond as the index.
I think what they mean is that if the compiler has analyzed the code, not shown in the example, that comes before the if statement, and concluded that unless something undefined happens, cond can only be 0 or 1, then it can optimize out the condition.
They are not saying that the code actually shown is enough to conclude that cond must be 0 or 1.