News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Board Game at the Heart of Viking Culture by cjslep on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @03:05PM (#17410857)
How many modern games are two-player asymmetrical? I only know of Android: Netrunner.

I hope we can continue learning more concrete rules for the ancient version of this game. It would be nice to have its history understood like chess'.

Re:The Board Game at the Heart of Viking Culture by jamesgeck0 on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @03:13PM (#17410926)
Steve Jackson Games first title was _Ogre_, a tactics game that pit an entire army against a single super unit.

Mr. Jack is another reasonably popular modern one.

The asymmetric tag on Board Game Geek is probably a good place to start. https://boardgamegeek.com/tag/asymmetric/page/1

Re:The Board Game at the Heart of Viking Culture by harlanlewis on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @06:03PM (#17412233)
Love board game geek. A little buried on that page is a link to ranked list of asymmetric games: https://boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/82677/asymmetric-games
Re:The Board Game at the Heart of Viking Culture by tialaramex on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @07:47PM (#17412885)
Many modern games are asymmetrical to some extent, although this does make "balancing" the game (often an important QA element of good games) more difficult.

Most modern territory control games will be somewhat asymmetrical because the territory isn't just abstract squares, hexes or whatever. For example in "London" players control London boroughs, and so this influences the play slightly. That would be at the very mildest end of the spectrum.

On the other end you have things like Star Wars Imperial Assault, where one person is playing the Empire while all other players control Rebels, their objectives are obviously very different (Imperial players generally seek to incapacitate the players or stall them until overwhelming forces become available, Rebels usually want to act quickly and use the element of surprise).

You also have some very non-crunchy games like Zendo. In Zendo one person is a "master" who has chosen some secret rule for what gives configurations of game pieces the "Buddha nature", everybody else makes new configurations and uses a process of asking questions or making guesses to try to figure out what the rule is. Some simple play mechanics keep this structured, but it's not really a competitive game at all.

Re:The Board Game at the Heart of Viking Culture by smogcutter on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @04:45PM (#17411708)
Wargames come to mind, both in board game and miniatures/tabletop form. There are loads, but here's an example: https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/62222/commands-colors-na...
Re:The Board Game at the Heart of Viking Culture by a1369209993 on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @09:36PM (#17413406)
Strictly speaking most modern (two-player) games are two-player asymmetrical, since one player has a first-mover advantage. Not what you meant of course, but worth considering; it's somewhat hard to make a game that's strictly symmetric.
Re:The Board Game at the Heart of Viking Culture by Someone on Thursday June 28, 2018 @03:22AM (#17414753)
Rock-paper-scissors is strictly symmetrical. Diplomacy would be, if started on a symmetrical map.

Also, take any two-player game, and create a new game where the players play the original game twice, switching sides, and you end up with a symmetrical game.

If you play both games in parallel, where each player can choose in which source game to play on each turn, I think you still end up with a symmetrical game (in some sense)

Re:The Board Game at the Heart of Viking Culture by formalsystem on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @05:45PM (#17412092)
I believe Viking chess is the first recorded example of an asymmetrical game.

In more modern times, many RTS games are asymmetrical: think SC2, Dota etc..

If you're thinking about board games, in particular, there's games like Terra Mystica or most miniature games that are designed with a vast number of factions that have differing goals.

Asymmetrical games are in fact hugely popular because they let people roleplay strategies that they may think are more fun

Re:The Board Game at the Heart of Viking Culture by hollerith on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @06:56PM (#17412606)
Starcraft (provided the players aren't both playing the same species).
Re:The Board Game at the Heart of Viking Culture by PhasmaFelis on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @11:09PM (#17413778)
Although even then both players pretty much have similar tools, similar resources, and similar goals. ("Gather minerals and gas, build a base and an army, destroy the other player's base and army.") I can't offhand think of any videogames that are radically asymmetric (e.g. one guy is playing an RTS, the other is playing a shooter), though I'm sure there's something.
Re:The Board Game at the Heart of Viking Culture by jamesgeck0 on Thursday June 28, 2018 @06:08PM (#17420890)
There are a few of them.

_Spy Party_ is a game in which one player is a sniper and the other player is a spy at a cocktail party pretending to be an NPC.

In _Who's Your Daddy_, one player is a father whose goal is child-proof their surroundings on the fly to thwart the other player, a suicidal baby.

_Evolve_ was a game in which a team of four hunter players hunted a single monster player.

_Natural Selection_ is close to what you describe; one player on each team is playing an RTS and their teammates are playing a FPS. One side is space marines, the other are aliens. Marines have guns, but aliens can move through vents, scuttle up walls, etc.

Re:The Board Game at the Heart of Viking Culture by LyndsySimon on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @09:06PM (#17413260)
Tic-tac-toe comes to mind...