News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The impossibility—and the necessity—of distinguishing sci... by crazydoggers on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @08:31AM (#17407586)
I’m sorry, but why is the neo-con anti science article on HN?

The article is attempting to say that modern particle physics is not science because there are a ton of failed experiments to find exotic particles and test theories.

This is how science works!! Your doing science correctly if you fail a lot. Yes it costs money to set up an experiment that fails to prove a hypothesis. That’s just science.

Read more about “The Weekly Standard” here..

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Weekly_Standard

Edit: Here’s an excerpt

“Of course the standard explanation of the difficulties with theoretical physics would simply be that science advances by failing, that it is self-correcting over time, and that all this flailing about is just what has to happen when you’re trying to understand something hard. Some version of this sort of failing-forward story is what Hossenfelder hears from many of her colleagues. But if all this activity is just self-correction in action, then why not call alchemy, astrology, phrenology, eugenics, and scientific socialism science as well...”

Umm... seriously?

Re:The impossibility—and the necessity—of distinguishing sci... by coldtea on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @09:06AM (#17407807)
>I’m sorry, but why is the neo-con anti science article on HN?

Knee-jerk labelling much? What exactly do you disagree with the article with and why?

Reading things outside of one's echo chamber and comfort zone is not something to be avoided. Even if it's something "anti-science" and "neo-con" -- you get to learn the ACTUAL points of anti-science people and neo-cons (as opposed to just second-hand reading your favorite writers disparaging their claims)

Re:The impossibility—and the necessity—of distinguishing sci... by 131012 on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @09:13AM (#17407859)
Because the underpinning theories are bullshit and been abandoned for almost 20 years in serious sociological circles. I gave more arguments lower in the comments.
Re:The impossibility—and the necessity—of distinguishing sci... by crazydoggers on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @09:13AM (#17407858)
Okay, shall we upvote articles about how the earth is flat, or how evolution is false? Those are outside the echo chamber.

How about considering if an article has points that are valid rather than nut case propaganda.

Re:The impossibility—and the necessity—of distinguishing sci... by coldtea on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @10:29AM (#17408382)
>Okay, shall we upvote articles about how the earth is flat, or how evolution is false?

Why not? The scientific method doesn't preclude anything a priori.

>How about considering if an article has points that are valid rather than nut case propaganda.

Where is this consideration though? And where are the counter arguments? I only see a quick labelling?

Re:The impossibility—and the necessity—of distinguishing sci... by crazydoggers on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @11:09AM (#17408725)
> Why not? The scientific method doesn't preclude anything a priori.

You're right it doesn't. But my criteria for an interesting and worthwhile article isn't one about crazy ideas that have been beaten to death 1000s of times already. If HN front page had tons of those types of stories, no one would come here!

Re:The impossibility—and the necessity—of distinguishing sci... by maxerickson on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @09:59AM (#17408133)
This is maybe an unfortunate approach if someone opens a restaurant called "Dog Shit".
Re:The impossibility—and the necessity—of distinguishing sci... by coldtea on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @10:27AM (#17408371)
You'd be surprised.

Many good restaurants have unfortunate names. And many very bad restaurants have pleasant names.

Even when it comes to "dog shit" it pays to do one's research...

Re:The impossibility—and the necessity—of distinguishing sci... by jonstewart on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @08:58AM (#17407745)
It's hard to think of a publication that has done more to degrade science over the entirety of its lifetime. The Weekly Standard is how we wound up with Darwin deniers serving on Congressional science & technology committees.
Re:The impossibility—and the necessity—of distinguishing sci... by dwaltrip on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @10:49AM (#17408551)
Links?

I'm a very strong science supporter and found the article to have some interesting (yet debatable) points. I'd like to know if that publication isn't reputable. I haven't seen it before.

Re:The impossibility—and the necessity—of distinguishing sci... by crazydoggers on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @11:16AM (#17408800)
Calling climate change a religion: https://www.weeklystandard.com/irwin-m-stelzer/the-sacred-sc...

Some Hawking bashing about climate change: https://www.weeklystandard.com/nathan-cofnas/dadaist-science

Or how about some Bill Nye smashing: https://www.weeklystandard.com/the-scrapbook/bill-nye-the-qu...

An attempt to show that Democrats are astrologers: https://www.weeklystandard.com/the-scrapbook/anti-science-li...

This list goes on...

Re:The impossibility—and the necessity—of distinguishing sci... by dwaltrip on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @04:06PM (#17411354)
Thanks for finding those links. Good to know more about the publication.
Re:The impossibility—and the necessity—of distinguishing sci... by 3pt14159 on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @09:36AM (#17407966)
Disclosure: Even though I'm a centre-left neo-liberal, I've written an article that appeared in The Weekly Standard. I wanted to make sure that the GOP controlled US government saw it.

It is true that the Weekly Standard is right wing—they make no qualms about it—but it is not true that they mis-report facts. Bill Kristol (editor at large) is a vocal supporter of the Never Trump movement and he is against fake news of all types.

https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/weekly-standard/

The core point at the centre of this article is interesting (the boundaries of what is and isn't science aren't well demarked), but I agree that the author makes his point in a way that isn't how I would have written it.

Re:The impossibility—and the necessity—of distinguishing sci... by emodendroket on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @10:38AM (#17408464)
It is interesting that you chose to elide the last part of that sentence, which completes the thought.
Re:The impossibility—and the necessity—of distinguishing sci... by crazydoggers on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @08:34AM (#17407610)
Immediately downvoted without comment. Clearly someone here is attempting to push these neo-con anti-science pieces as news.
Re:The impossibility—and the necessity—of distinguishing sci... by sctb on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @01:15PM (#17409948)
Could you please stop with these off-topic insinuations? They're rather unscientific. If you have concerns, the guidelines ask you to email [email protected] so we can look at the data.