News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Obsessive Search for the Tasmanian Tiger by danieltillett on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @05:27AM (#17406822)
This is not exactly convincing. They admit that everywhere else in the world this doesn't happen, but somehow it happens in Australia. Given all these stories have appeared in recent time I am not convinced.

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

Re:The Obsessive Search for the Tasmanian Tiger by Sevrene on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @06:01AM (#17406967)
Aboriginals passed down their history and culture orally, so you can't really expect them to provide evidence other than their retelling. I don't think anyone is saying that the Dreamtime stories are 100% true, but it was probably influenced by something. The question is how much is story, and how much is fact?

The tree sisters story [1] (which was actually taught in schools) is apparently completely fake and the modern highway network apparently resembles the way aboriginals navigated Australia too [2]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Sisters_(Australia)#Abor...

[2] https://theconversation.com/how-ancient-aboriginal-star-maps...

Re:The Obsessive Search for the Tasmanian Tiger by danieltillett on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @06:34AM (#17407098)
They are just stories like every other culture in the world has and are as unreliable as a form of history as everyone else's oral histories (myths).

Aboriginal people are just people and they don't have some magically ability that allows information to be passed down via oral transmission through 300 generations.

Edit. The huge diversity of Aboriginal languages is proof that information was not transmitted accurately. If you can't even preserve the word for "foot" (just an example) down 300 generations how can it be expected that a story of even less practical utility and far greater complexity would be maintained accurately. The whole idea is ludicrous.

Re:The Obsessive Search for the Tasmanian Tiger by jbattle on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @10:21AM (#17408331)
Pure speculation: but the Aborigines are AFAIK relatively unique in their cultural isolation. Contrast this to any tribe living in Asia+Africa+Europe where migration over large scales definitely happened and cultural diffusion across thousands of miles and hundreds of distinct cultures was very possible.

I could see where this kind of cultural and physical mixing (migration) could dilute or mutate folk tales, washing out distinctive 'fact-derived' aspects of the stories

Re:The Obsessive Search for the Tasmanian Tiger by danieltillett on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @04:43PM (#17411688)
Actually there was quite a large amount of migration within Australia, it is just hard to track do to the lack of distinct cultural artifacts that survive over time.

The Basques have been where there are for a long time and they have had a oral culture for most of the time and yet their myths are not any more factual than anyone else's.

Re:The Obsessive Search for the Tasmanian Tiger by ubernostrum on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @12:44PM (#17409646)
Oral cultures are... different from what we're used to. There's a fair bit of research on this (Walter Ong is your starting point if you want to start diving into it).

Without debating whether the information preserved is factually accurate, it's known that oral cultures develop interesting and complex -- from an information-theoretical perspective -- mechanisms for preserving information, and for making it possible to retain accurately in memory amounts of information that tend to shock people from cultures oriented around writing as the means of information preservation.

Re:The Obsessive Search for the Tasmanian Tiger by danieltillett on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @04:50PM (#17411748)
Yes oral cultures are different, but you don't have to go far back in European history to run across cultures that were oral (Anglo Saxon if we want to stay with English history). While a great epic poem of oral tradition, nobody today would consider Beowulf anything other than a complete work of fiction.

If your cultures can't preserve basic words, what possible mechanism could preserve useless facts in complex stories who's purpose is purely to entertain around the campfire?

Re:The Obsessive Search for the Tasmanian Tiger by ubernostrum on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @05:41PM (#17412062)
Preserving something important to the culture is not identical with ensuring the language freezes and can never change further.

And if you don't think the old oral epics have value -- you seem not to -- then I don't know that it's really worth discussing them with you.

Re:The Obsessive Search for the Tasmanian Tiger by danieltillett on Thursday June 28, 2018 @01:50AM (#17414401)
It is not that I don’t think oral story don’t have value (they are entertaining), I just don’t think they contain any facts after a few generation. Myths are fiction.
Re:The Obsessive Search for the Tasmanian Tiger by ubernostrum on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:54AM (#17477281)
Oral cultures did manage to preserve plenty of facts.

Their epics just weren't intended for that purpose. You might as well criticize modern literate America for the vast quantities of fact-free written material being churned out.

Re:The Obsessive Search for the Tasmanian Tiger by btilly on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @01:03PM (#17409840)
Actually it does happen elsewhere in the world. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folk_memory for a few examples.

However there is an odd problem. There is evidence that literacy is in direct conflict with memorizing complex oral traditions. Oral traditions can be surprisingly long - for a well-known example consider that Homer's works were preserved as an oral tradition. People who can read and write are unable to memorize works of this length. And anthropologists learned the hard way that teaching someone who has already memorized things of this length causes them to forget what they previously knew.

Re:The Obsessive Search for the Tasmanian Tiger by danieltillett on Thursday June 28, 2018 @01:59AM (#17414430)
These are not exactly convincing examples especially when near identical examples of these stories are found other cultures where they are accepted as pure myth.

Most oral epics and stories were never intended to accurately transmit facts about the past. The idea of history as based on facts is a very recent idea and it is one of the reasons we have so many problems with the written records from ancient historians. They had no problem making up entire stores and conversations that never happened as long as it furthered the purpose of their writing.

The purpose of these oral traditions is not to transmit facts, but to explain to the next generation what is important to their culture and/or entertain.

Re:The Obsessive Search for the Tasmanian Tiger by RVuRnvbM2e on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @06:11AM (#17407013)
There are multiple similar examples. Here's one backed up with genetic evidence.

https://www.nature.com/articles/520033a

Re:The Obsessive Search for the Tasmanian Tiger by danieltillett on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @06:29AM (#17407076)
This one has come up before here on HN. Apart from the obvious fact that there are only four major points on the compass and so chance could be 100% responsible for this story, aboriginal people travelled around and would have seen these palms to the north. Take out the gods from the story and the story is exactly what would be expected - where are the palms from - oh they come from the north.